Page 3 of 11

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 5:24 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Aussie wrote: December 7th, 2023, 10:41 pm
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 7th, 2023, 7:50 pm
kirtland r.m. wrote: December 7th, 2023, 7:23 pm Here is my take on church leaders after many years of studying and living the gospel in the church. This is it, and not more or less is right. The Lord will replace any high church leader if they get too far off track and don't quickly get back on. The church and priesthood will remain on the earth from this time, never to be taken again through the Lord's second coming (see D&C 13 among other scripture). Should the Prophet go astray or need special guidance, our Lord will provide it in the due time to fulfil his purposes. He can visit and speak with the Prophet any time he wishes. We must be ready to receive revelation. We could print this and put it in a frame or on the refrigerator with a magnet. ;) ;) . This is all scripturally sound and true doctrine. It will not change. Once we understand it, we need to be ready to follow the spirit to be completely as far as humanly possible, making correct and righteous judgements and decisions.
Interesting how “my take” is nearly the opposite, after studying the scriptures, specifically the teachings of Christ.

JST Mark 9 would suggest that he won’t “replace” a leader, he invited us to trust in the Lord alone.

The righteous will remain on the Earth. In fact, the Lord specifically prophesied that he’d remove his gospel from wicked and apostate religions.

The Lord can and will raise up any number of prophets from various segment of society and cultures. The Lord and nearly all ancient prophets prophesied about the derelict nature of modern religious leaders. The LDS org is the epitome of apostasy and dereliction.
Yes that is right! Most of those leaders are the real apostates and have been since Brigham. He brought in the 'Satanic Adam God Theory' and it was taught for twenty five years! That's not just off track that's of the planet! The leaders and most of the members have apostatized and that's why the Davidic leaders coming and his name is David! He will complete the restoration and take all the scriptures and records from the gentiles and give them to the Jews. This is the fulfilling of the gentiles coming very soon!
I have a slightly different take on who the Lord will take the “fullness of the gospel”, I believe the “House of Israel” is anyone who has a broken heart and contrite spirit and receive a personal commission from the Lord. If you think about it, how much blood from Jerusalem is here in America already? How much native american blood is mixed with Gentile blood? And how many are simply adopted into the House of Israel by their humility and willingness to follow the Lord?

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 5:25 am
by Reluctant Watchman
kirtland r.m. wrote: December 7th, 2023, 10:48 pm
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 7th, 2023, 9:16 pm
kirtland r.m. wrote: December 7th, 2023, 9:14 pm

So you always revert to your default position, the church leaders are liars. Good luck on that one. You sure seem to expend a lot of energy and time on a l.d.s. oriented site for no apparent reason then.
Did Jesus teach that even a true prophet CAN lead you astray? Yes. Do you deny that?

Mormon didn’t just call them liars, he called them hypocrites who polluted the church.

Nephi taught that they changed the doctrine and grind the face of the poor. This example of WW epitomizes the derelict nature of LDS leaders. They know they are teaching false doctrine.
Man some of you guys are goofy on this forum. If you can't even agree with me on what we have already talked about, let's see how you explain this. Deuteronomy 18:22 NKJV when a prophet speaks in the name of the LORD, if the thing does not happen or come to pass, that is the thing which the LORD has not spoken; the prophet has spoken it presumptuously; you shall not be afraid of him. I am sure your comments will be mighty interesting. Maybe Moses lied as well? I'll be waiting.
Again, no answer for JST Mark 9.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 5:47 am
by BroJones
Atrasado wrote: December 7th, 2023, 1:06 pm
rimbauer.peter wrote: December 7th, 2023, 12:53 pm "Spiritually speaking I am a rootbound tree growing in a pot inside of a house. I want to be outside where I can stretch my roots deeply into the soil and I want to produce good fruit and shade for the weary. I want to protect smaller plants. I want to grow strong enough to handle the wind in my branches. I want the sunlight to shine down on me. I did not put myself in the pot but that pot is limiting my growth in many ways." <--- This is a perfect summary of how I think about and experience the way of Christ. I will definitely save this writing of yours because it strengthens one's soul and helps move forward. Even if one is alone, the most important thing in this mortal life and in eternity itself is the knowledge and testimony of Christ. He who follows him will never be led astray.
The thought that came to me yesterday is that the institutional Church is killing the spiritual Church. One of the two has to go.
I love the Book of Mormon - "our latter-day survival guide"!

I wonder what will happen to the corporation's $160+ Billion when the stock market crashes, or when Babylon the great falls - as it surely will! Slippery riches, as the Book of Mormon warns.

Heber C. Kimball prophesied of a great "SIFTING" - and it seems this is happening now. Wait though till Babylon the great falls!

John warns us to "Come out of Babylon" lest we be partakers of her plagues and destruction (Revelation)...

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 5:50 am
by Reluctant Watchman
BroJones wrote: December 8th, 2023, 5:47 am
Atrasado wrote: December 7th, 2023, 1:06 pm
rimbauer.peter wrote: December 7th, 2023, 12:53 pm "Spiritually speaking I am a rootbound tree growing in a pot inside of a house. I want to be outside where I can stretch my roots deeply into the soil and I want to produce good fruit and shade for the weary. I want to protect smaller plants. I want to grow strong enough to handle the wind in my branches. I want the sunlight to shine down on me. I did not put myself in the pot but that pot is limiting my growth in many ways." <--- This is a perfect summary of how I think about and experience the way of Christ. I will definitely save this writing of yours because it strengthens one's soul and helps move forward. Even if one is alone, the most important thing in this mortal life and in eternity itself is the knowledge and testimony of Christ. He who follows him will never be led astray.
The thought that came to me yesterday is that the institutional Church is killing the spiritual Church. One of the two has to go.
I love the Book of Mormon - "our latter-day survival guide"!

I wonder what will happen to the corporation's $160+ Billion when the stock market crashes, or when Babylon the great falls - as it surely will! Slippery riches, as the Book of Mormon warns.

Heber C. Kimball prophesied of a great "SIFTING" - and it seems this is happening now. Wait though till Babylon the great falls!

John warns us to "Come out of Babylon" lest we be partakers of her plagues and destruction (Revelation)...
Bro Jones, total tangent here, but did you see the thread I started on the Brewer Cave? I’d be curious if you have more details since you are quoted in the video: viewtopic.php?t=73368

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 7:23 am
by TheChristian
Chip wrote: December 7th, 2023, 10:21 pm
solonan wrote: December 7th, 2023, 10:13 pm
TheChristian wrote: December 7th, 2023, 11:57 am If I was amongst your people I would speak about Jesus all the day long, give help to the helpless, the lonely and the sick, when ever your Fast and testimony meetings occured I would arise and speak about Calvary, of my Saviours love for us all, I would sing your hyms at the top of my voice and from my heart in all your communion meetings......
If you feel you have something to offer, let it be your faith in Christ, let it burn brightly that others might gain comfort, warmth and joy from it...........
To walk away from a sick church, is like walking away from a sickly elderly mother that gave you birth, return to her, your church and be that vibrant healing balm in her midst............
Jesus gave His lifes blood for the people in your church, you his disciple must carry your cross into your church and hold it up high for all the weary and heavy laden to see that they might have hope and turn to the Lord of Glory with all their hearts and find joy and peace for their souls.
Absolutely true! Amen! Amen! Amen!

What If the people just relish in idolatry of the church and it's leaders and, to them, a testimony of Jesus without praise for the prophet is like a sundae without the ice cream?
My brother the preaching of the Cross, of that Holy One that hung apon it, can melt and warm the coldest of hearts and rid the idolater of all his idols, there is a power indescribable that attends the fervent testimony of the Lord Jesus.
I could tell many a story of the power of Jesus of Nazerath in action when a simple witness to His name and His living reality has been uttered by poor unlearned men whoms only wealth was their faith.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 8:34 am
by Sarah
Seed Starter wrote: December 6th, 2023, 9:42 pm I'm nearly done with my resignation letter. I will share when I'm done. I'm not leaving this forum but I'm done white-knuckling my membership in the LDS church. The cognitive dissonance is too much for me to tolerate a minute longer. I'm feeling a great deal of weight this evening. Not because I'm unsure about my decision but because I feel locked in the cage of my birth. Pulling myself through the bars is painful. I've been a member for over half a century (my entire life) and I know what to expect from some family and even some friends. I feel conditioned not to do what I'm doing and I never thought it would be so uncomfortable to reject the conditioning.

I've spent over 3 years praying, studying the scriptures, pondering, and researching this decision. I'm extremely sad because in my opinion the corporate church contradicts the Gospel of Christ and many of its leaders aren't who they said they were. I feel like my trust was taken advantage of in many ways. I love Christ and His gospel. He is my rock and the only way to salvation. I believe in the Book of Mormon. I believe the Holy Ghost can confirm the truth of all things. The crazy thing is my love for those two things is why I'm separating myself from the corporate church. I believe I've come to understand the difference between a mistake and wanton disobedience to Christ. Spiritually speaking I am a rootbound tree growing in a pot inside of a house. I want to be outside where I can stretch my roots deeply into the soil and I want to produce good fruit and shade for the weary. I want to protect smaller plants. I want to grow strong enough to handle the wind in my branches. I want the sunlight to shine down on me. I did not put myself in the pot but that pot is limiting my growth in many ways.

I realize many members are on this site and I have no ill will toward them. I appreciate all of the things I've been taught by all of you wonderful people. Even in disagreement, there are lessons for me to learn. I appreciate the acts of kindness I've experienced here. This feels like my home ward. Thank you! I would appreciate anyone who feels like praying for me and my family to do so.
The Church is true and still holds Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes by leaders or members. The people are the Church, and we are a family. And we all know no family is perfect, and neither is any leader or member in the church. But the apostleship has not been taken away as it was before. The ordinances and covenants are gifts from God that seal you legally into his family. You need both the relationship with God, and the binding covenant done through Priesthood Keys to make your relationship legal or binding in heaven.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 8:42 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 8:34 am
The Church is true and still holds Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes by leaders or members. The people are the Church, and we are a family. And we all know no family is perfect, and neither is any leader or member in the church. But the apostleship has not been taken away as it was before. The ordinances and covenants are gifts from God that seal you legally into his family. You need both the relationship with God, and the binding covenant done through Priesthood Keys to make your relationship legal or binding in heaven.
So did King Noah retain "Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes"?

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:24 am
by Sarah
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 8:42 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 8:34 am
The Church is true and still holds Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes by leaders or members. The people are the Church, and we are a family. And we all know no family is perfect, and neither is any leader or member in the church. But the apostleship has not been taken away as it was before. The ordinances and covenants are gifts from God that seal you legally into his family. You need both the relationship with God, and the binding covenant done through Priesthood Keys to make your relationship legal or binding in heaven.
So did King Noah retain "Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes"?
If he did have authority given to him to perform ordinances, then those ordinances would still be valid. If a Bishop is committing adultery, any ordinances he approves or performs would still be valid. It just means we as members don't have to partake of the same sin. What is important too though is who on earth holds all the Priesthood Keys. Noah may not have had authority to call other Priests, but it sounds like Alma was ordained in the time of Zeniff, Noah's father, and who was a righteous man.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am
by John Tavner
Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:34 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:24 am If he did have authority given to him to perform ordinances, then those ordinances would still be valid. If a Bishop is committing adultery, any ordinances he approves or performs would still be valid. It just means we as members don't have to partake of the same sin. What is important too though is who on earth holds all the Priesthood Keys. Noah may not have had authority to call other Priests, but it sounds like Alma was ordained in the time of Zeniff, Noah's father, and who was a righteous man.
I disagree. The Lord alone commissions and authorizes his servants. Priesthood and authority (keys) do not transfer through hands on heads. Alma received a personal commission from the Lord. The BoM does not expressly state that, but the Nemenhah Records does.

Personally, I believe the ordinances themselves have become corrupt, so to me that invalidates the Lord's blessings regardless of any supposed keys and authority.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:40 am
by Reluctant Watchman
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
Any many of the offshoot LDS branches.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:40 am
by Simon
Seed Starter wrote: December 6th, 2023, 9:42 pm I'm nearly done with my resignation letter. I will share when I'm done. I'm not leaving this forum but I'm done white-knuckling my membership in the LDS church. The cognitive dissonance is too much for me to tolerate a minute longer. I'm feeling a great deal of weight this evening. Not because I'm unsure about my decision but because I feel locked in the cage of my birth. Pulling myself through the bars is painful. I've been a member for over half a century (my entire life) and I know what to expect from some family and even some friends. I feel conditioned not to do what I'm doing and I never thought it would be so uncomfortable to reject the conditioning.

I've spent over 3 years praying, studying the scriptures, pondering, and researching this decision. I'm extremely sad because in my opinion the corporate church contradicts the Gospel of Christ and many of its leaders aren't who they said they were. I feel like my trust was taken advantage of in many ways. I love Christ and His gospel. He is my rock and the only way to salvation. I believe in the Book of Mormon. I believe the Holy Ghost can confirm the truth of all things. The crazy thing is my love for those two things is why I'm separating myself from the corporate church. I believe I've come to understand the difference between a mistake and wanton disobedience to Christ. Spiritually speaking I am a rootbound tree growing in a pot inside of a house. I want to be outside where I can stretch my roots deeply into the soil and I want to produce good fruit and shade for the weary. I want to protect smaller plants. I want to grow strong enough to handle the wind in my branches. I want the sunlight to shine down on me. I did not put myself in the pot but that pot is limiting my growth in many ways.

I realize many members are on this site and I have no ill will toward them. I appreciate all of the things I've been taught by all of you wonderful people. Even in disagreement, there are lessons for me to learn. I appreciate the acts of kindness I've experienced here. This feels like my home ward. Thank you! I would appreciate anyone who feels like praying for me and my family to do so.
Just today I wrote a response to a comment on Youtube, and I have no idea whether this is in any way benefitial to you, but it helped me greatly on my journey, and so I hope you don't mind me posting this.. Understanding this has allowed me to love the good in the church, and yet to still be authentic about its downfalls, and it brought somewhat peace into my life... Not everything may be relevant to your situation, but I still hope its okay to just share it..

Here it is (you may notice it was a response to a Evangelical) :)

God equals truth (John 14:6), meaning, everyone that embraces truth, though he may not specifically know about the law, or about the God standing behind that truth, still honors God by living and loving that truth, becoming a law unto themselves, having the law (as well as the spirit of God) written in their hearts (Romans 2:15-15)

God equals love (1 John 4:8), meaning, those that love do not just fulfill the law (Romans 13:8), but also “know God” (1 John 4:8), and by “knowing God”, have “eternal life” (John 17:3).. Hence, the invitation to "above all, love one another" (1 Peter 4:8), along with the clarification that "there is no greater love, than to lay down your life for your friends (John 15:13), which to me is not just referring to dying, but also to serving others selflessly.

Personally I love the parable of the “good Samaritan” in that regard, because from the perspective of the Jews, the Samaritans were pagans, believing in a false interpretation of the scriptures and of God. And yet he was the one whom Christ considered to be “good”, not because he got every doctrine right, or because he worshiped a perfectly accurate interpretation of God in the exact right way, but simply because he showed mercy and charity.

So when I refer to “love”, do I not refer to "just being “kind”, but I refer to the kind of charity Paul talks about, the kind of love that leads to long-suffering, kindness, meekness, patience, forgiveness, selflessness, that loves truth above all lies, though these lies may be someone's present truth etc.

In other words, I can see how a dude on a remote isle land that never heard anything about God or the Bible, may “know God” more than the most devout Christian next door that certainly may know everything “about God”, even brining forth all sorts of works, faith, miracles, gifts of the spirit, knowing and understanding all of Gods mysteries, sacrificing his entire life for God, but yet still fails to “know God” in all his doings due to lack of charity.
And Paul clearly seems to affirm when stating that even when people know all about God, bringing forth all these signs and wonders, that there is no value to it if not rooted in charity (1 Corinth. 13).

And so I agree with Moroni from the Book of Mormon when he states that "everything which inviteth and enticeth to good .. is of God".. or in other words, everything that brings forth within ourselves the "good fruit of charity" is of God.
Jesus, when talking about discerning true from false Prophets in these last days (and from my experience this principle of discernment works on everything), he very clearly states that "ye shall know them by their fruits" (Matthew 7), indicating that once we tasted of that “good fruit”, we can know without ANY doubt, that the tree where it's coming from (meaning the source of the truth claim, whether that be the Prophets, the Bible, a religion, or visions and dreams etc.).

So obviously the “good fruit” can not refer to anything that can be corrupted in any way, be manipulated in any way, be turned into an idle in any way, which according to Paul can happen though with works, faith, miracles, the gifts of the spirit, great sacrifices, and even to the knowing and understanding of all mysteries of God, if it lacks charity, and yes, that even includes the Bible, which can be made an idle if it replaces what "knowing God "should be all about. The “good fruit” can not even refer to “charity” we see within others, because they can still fake that charity, or pretend it for “unrighteous reasons”.

So, the only thing that can neither be turned into an idle, nor be manipulated, nor be deceptive, and with that qualifies to be "the good fruit" Jesus talked about, by which we are to discern spiritual truth from deception, is the charity that is brought forth “within ourselves”, meaning, everything that inspires anyone to bring forth that kind of long-suffering, kindness, meekness, patience, forgiveness etc, if of God, and everyone that "becomes" that kind of charity, knows God, and everyone that knows God, will obtain eternal life, something that works especially great with the LDS doctrine that God has the desire and is powerful enough to want "everyone to be saved and understand truth" (1 Tim. 2: 4-6), preparing ways that everyone, whether in this life or in the next, will be allowed to come to a full understanding of Jesus Christ, for he is the center of all truth, and he will not judge people to hell that have honored him, known him, though they may not have known anything about him.

In that sense do I see a great purpose, a great divine plan, great mercy and justice in God having created a world with so much diversity. There is divine purpose behind all the different religions and world views, and in my view that proves that God can and should never be limited to one world view, one interpretation or even one set of books that basically proves that God cares more about preserving a inerrant book for thousand of years to save a tiny portion of his own creations, but obviously lacks the power and/or desire to apply the same kind of principle upon his own creations.

As I see it, God works on a much larger scale.

If we are to believe James, then all of us, whether saved or unsaved, whether Christian or Muslim, whether black or white, will one day receive the exact kind of mercy from God, that we have extended towards others (James 2:13). It will be our own mercy, that will "rejoice against judgement", and what greater mercy can there be than the one rooted on the pure love of Christ?

So I conclude here with C.S. Lewis, who put it this way:

“It is as well to put this the other way round. Some of us who seem quite nice people may, in fact, have made so little use of a good heredity and good upbringing that we are really worse than those whom we regard as fiends. Can we be quite certain how we should have behaved if we had been saddled with the psychological outfit, and then with the bad upbringing, and then with the power, say, of Himmler?

That is why Christians are told not to judge.

We see only the results which a man's choices make out of his raw material. But God does not judge him on the raw material at all, but on what he has done with it. Most of the man's psychological makeup is probably due to his body: when his body dies all that will fall off him, and the real central man, the thing that chose, that made the best or worst out of this material, will stand naked.

All sorts of nice things which we thought our own, but which were really due to a good digestion, will fall off some of us: all sorts of nasty things which were due to complexes or bad health will fall off others. We shall then, for the first time, see every one as he really was.

There will be surprises.”

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:41 am
by Sarah
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
The apostles were taken from the earth along with the fullness of Priesthood Keys.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:46 am
by Sarah
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:34 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:24 am If he did have authority given to him to perform ordinances, then those ordinances would still be valid. If a Bishop is committing adultery, any ordinances he approves or performs would still be valid. It just means we as members don't have to partake of the same sin. What is important too though is who on earth holds all the Priesthood Keys. Noah may not have had authority to call other Priests, but it sounds like Alma was ordained in the time of Zeniff, Noah's father, and who was a righteous man.
I disagree. The Lord alone commissions and authorizes his servants. Priesthood and authority (keys) do not transfer through hands on heads. Alma received a personal commission from the Lord. The BoM does not expressly state that, but the Nemenhah Records does.

Personally, I believe the ordinances themselves have become corrupt, so to me that invalidates the Lord's blessings regardless of any supposed keys and authority.
The New Testament and Book of Mormon reference authority given by the laying on of hands. We are also as the children of Israel, who had a system for who held Priesthood authority to perform ordinances. The Lord does not have to personally visit each individual to make covenants with them.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:47 am
by Sarah
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:40 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
Any many of the offshoot LDS branches.
There is only one on the earth at a time who holds all the Keys or authority to perform all the ordinances.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:49 am
by John Tavner
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:41 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
The apostles were taken from the earth along with the fullness of Priesthood Keys.
According to who? See the funny thing about keys is they can just be handed around by laying hands on people's heads (at least the way The LDS church use them). So there isn't a need to be an Apostle to have all the keys. No rule anywhere says that. If there is a rule, then we need to discuss what an Apostle really is - and then discuss whether or not those who claim to be apostles are really apostles. At the very least. The bishopric still exists in the catholic church according to the way LDS people use the term keys.

We have a lot of traditions that say things... but very little source material for it... most of our tradtional views derive from about 2-3 generations after J.Smith.

Additionally I would ask what is the "fullness" of priesthood keys. Can you have "halfness?" of priesthood keys? So that can be passed around by laying on of hands? Sounds like there are probably milions of people not LDS that still have keys because hands were laid upon their head and what they ahve is perfectly valid because they've been passed down for generations.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:54 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:46 am
The New Testament and Book of Mormon reference authority given by the laying on of hands. We are also as the children of Israel, who had a system for who held Priesthood authority to perform ordinances. The Lord does not have to personally visit each individual to make covenants with them.
Yes, those records do mention the process, but my point is that simply the action does not confer rights or authority. It must be commissioned by the Lord. IMO it doesn't have to be a personal visit, but certainly a commission received via personal revelation.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 9:55 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:47 am
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:40 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
Any many of the offshoot LDS branches.
There is only one on the earth at a time who holds all the Keys or authority to perform all the ordinances.
Then why have 12 ordained in Jerusalem and another 12 in the New World? What you are proposing is a dictatorship. The Lord can do as He pleases, and that includes being free to give his authority to many people.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:08 am
by blitzinstripes
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:49 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:41 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
The apostles were taken from the earth along with the fullness of Priesthood Keys.
According to who? See the funny thing about keys is they can just be handed around by laying hands on people's heads (at least the way The LDS church use them). So there isn't a need to be an Apostle to have all the keys. No rule anywhere says that. If there is a rule, then we need to discuss what an Apostle really is - and then discuss whether or not those who claim to be apostles are really apostles. At the very least. The bishopric still exists in the catholic church according to the way LDS people use the term keys.

We have a lot of traditions that say things... but very little source material for it... most of our tradtional views derive from about 2-3 generations after J.Smith.

Additionally I would ask what is the "fullness" of priesthood keys. Can you have "halfness?" of priesthood keys? So that can be passed around by laying on of hands? Sounds like there are probably milions of people not LDS that still have keys because hands were laid upon their head and what they ahve is perfectly valid because they've been passed down for generations.
I'm afraid you're simply wasting your time, John. It's like she's copying and pasting her responses from a church manual or the PR department. I'm starting to believe she's incapable of an independent thought.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:12 am
by kirtland r.m.
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 8:34 am
Seed Starter wrote: December 6th, 2023, 9:42 pm I'm nearly done with my resignation letter. I will share when I'm done. I'm not leaving this forum but I'm done white-knuckling my membership in the LDS church. The cognitive dissonance is too much for me to tolerate a minute longer. I'm feeling a great deal of weight this evening. Not because I'm unsure about my decision but because I feel locked in the cage of my birth. Pulling myself through the bars is painful. I've been a member for over half a century (my entire life) and I know what to expect from some family and even some friends. I feel conditioned not to do what I'm doing and I never thought it would be so uncomfortable to reject the conditioning.

I've spent over 3 years praying, studying the scriptures, pondering, and researching this decision. I'm extremely sad because in my opinion the corporate church contradicts the Gospel of Christ and many of its leaders aren't who they said they were. I feel like my trust was taken advantage of in many ways. I love Christ and His gospel. He is my rock and the only way to salvation. I believe in the Book of Mormon. I believe the Holy Ghost can confirm the truth of all things. The crazy thing is my love for those two things is why I'm separating myself from the corporate church. I believe I've come to understand the difference between a mistake and wanton disobedience to Christ. Spiritually speaking I am a rootbound tree growing in a pot inside of a house. I want to be outside where I can stretch my roots deeply into the soil and I want to produce good fruit and shade for the weary. I want to protect smaller plants. I want to grow strong enough to handle the wind in my branches. I want the sunlight to shine down on me. I did not put myself in the pot but that pot is limiting my growth in many ways.

I realize many members are on this site and I have no ill will toward them. I appreciate all of the things I've been taught by all of you wonderful people. Even in disagreement, there are lessons for me to learn. I appreciate the acts of kindness I've experienced here. This feels like my home ward. Thank you! I would appreciate anyone who feels like praying for me and my family to do so.
The Church is true and still holds Priesthood authority despite any faults or past mistakes by leaders or members. The people are the Church, and we are a family. And we all know no family is perfect, and neither is any leader or member in the church. But the apostleship has not been taken away as it was before. The ordinances and covenants are gifts from God that seal you legally into his family. You need both the relationship with God, and the binding covenant done through Priesthood Keys to make your relationship legal or binding in heaven.
Well said, and who among us knows how many resources the Lord wants held in reserve and timing of the use or sale of some of them, for things will be more dicey as the days grow closer for the final tribulation period. The poor should be constantly helped in programs that don't just hand them a fish on a necessary day which can be vital, but also teach them how to fish. However, it would seem prudent for a reserve. It is my responsibility for me to provide this for my family if possible, it is the leaders responsibility to disperse sacred funds righteously using correct principles as well. Some will say the church has grown too rich and isn't helping the poor enough. Church leaders are in a better position to know than I am, and I know that they are using much of what they are stewards over, to help directly in many problems for many souls. Let them do their job. they with be accountable for it, and let us do ours.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:14 am
by Sarah
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:49 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:41 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
The apostles were taken from the earth along with the fullness of Priesthood Keys.
According to who? See the funny thing about keys is they can just be handed around by laying hands on people's heads (at least the way The LDS church use them). So there isn't a need to be an Apostle to have all the keys. No rule anywhere says that. If there is a rule, then we need to discuss what an Apostle really is - and then discuss whether or not those who claim to be apostles are really apostles. At the very least. The bishopric still exists in the catholic church according to the way LDS people use the term keys.

We have a lot of traditions that say things... but very little source material for it... most of our tradtional views derive from about 2-3 generations after J.Smith.

Additionally I would ask what is the "fullness" of priesthood keys. Can you have "halfness?" of priesthood keys? So that can be passed around by laying on of hands? Sounds like there are probably milions of people not LDS that still have keys because hands were laid upon their head and what they ahve is perfectly valid because they've been passed down for generations.
The Lord likes order and has a system he follows. Men does tend to mess things up, but he works with what he has. There is always a good, better, best, and we want to look for the best. The keys give someone authority to do something, so not everyone who has had hands laid on their head has keys, but they may have received a valid ordinance. The Lord says as well that these ordinances need to be recorded, and they are recorded in heaven as well. The church does all these things, and I feel there is evidence enough of the Lord not taking away the Keys given to all our prophets. I have my own witness of their validity as well. The fullness of the keys available would include all the temple ordinances.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:18 am
by Sarah
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:55 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:47 am
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:40 am
Any many of the offshoot LDS branches.
There is only one on the earth at a time who holds all the Keys or authority to perform all the ordinances.
Then why have 12 ordained in Jerusalem and another 12 in the New World? What you are proposing is a dictatorship. The Lord can do as He pleases, and that includes being free to give his authority to many people.
Yes, the Lord can do as he pleases, and in that case they were in a whole different world so to speak, but for our time, there is only one who holds keys to perform all the ordinances.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:21 am
by kirtland r.m.
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:49 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:41 am
John Tavner wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:33 am Sounds like the Catholic church is true then.
The apostles were taken from the earth along with the fullness of Priesthood Keys.
According to who? See the funny thing about keys is they can just be handed around by laying hands on people's heads (at least the way The LDS church use them). So there isn't a need to be an Apostle to have all the keys. No rule anywhere says that. If there is a rule, then we need to discuss what an Apostle really is - and then discuss whether or not those who claim to be apostles are really apostles. At the very least. The bishopric still exists in the catholic church according to the way LDS people use the term keys.

We have a lot of traditions that say things... but very little source material for it... most of our tradtional views derive from about 2-3 generations after J.Smith.

Additionally I would ask what is the "fullness" of priesthood keys. Can you have "halfness?" of priesthood keys? So that can be passed around by laying on of hands? Sounds like there are probably milions of people not LDS that still have keys because hands were laid upon their head and what they ahve is perfectly valid because they've been passed down for generations.
You might study gospel dispensations, there is no Halfness.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:26 am
by kirtland r.m.
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 10:18 am
Reluctant Watchman wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:55 am
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 9:47 am

There is only one on the earth at a time who holds all the Keys or authority to perform all the ordinances.
Then why have 12 ordained in Jerusalem and another 12 in the New World? What you are proposing is a dictatorship. The Lord can do as He pleases, and that includes being free to give his authority to many people.
Yes, the Lord can do as he pleases, and in that case they were in a whole different world so to speak, but for our time, there is only one who holds keys to perform all the ordinances.
Reluctant Watchman knows that those two groups of Apostles were separated by continents and he is creating a strawman argument. By the way, the Lord has absolute power to do this.

Re: My wife and I are resigning from the church tomorrow

Posted: December 8th, 2023, 10:30 am
by Reluctant Watchman
Sarah wrote: December 8th, 2023, 10:18 am Yes, the Lord can do as he pleases, and in that case they were in a whole different world so to speak, but for our time, there is only one who holds keys to perform all the ordinances.
Again, I have a different opinion. The man at the helm of the LDS church is the epitome of these verses:

37 That they may be conferred upon us, it is true; but when we undertake to cover our sins, or to gratify our pride, our vain ambition, or to exercise control or dominion or compulsion upon the souls of the children of men, in any degree of unrighteousness, behold, the heavens withdraw themselves; the Spirit of the Lord is grieved; and when it is withdrawn, Amen to the priesthood or the authority of that man.

If you are happy in the LDS church, great. While I can love my friends and family who remain, to remain in the church would be one of the most spiritually limiting things I could do.