If your argument is that the brethren do not manifest the fruits of prophecy, seership, and revelation at the same level as Joseph Smith and many prophets in the scriptures did, I think few will disagree. This however does not mean that they don't manifest them at all.Luke wrote: ↑September 11th, 2022, 3:46 pm The brethren don’t produce prophetic fruit. It’s as simple as that.
People who have read my posts know that I don’t have “an axe to grind” or whatever, because I don’t. I don’t let the brethren’s actions affect me because I’m simply not bothered. I live my religion according to the dictates of my own conscience. Sometimes I weigh in on something they’ve said or done but again, I don’t really care all that much.
I realised a while ago that there’s no point criticising their actions. I don’t agree with some of their actions, but I try not to criticise them for it. Why? Because I don’t know the reason for everything. Maybe there are reasons they are doing such things.
I would much rather criticise them from a doctrinal standpoint (i.e. point out that they don’t permit plural marriage or don’t administer second anointings as an essential ordinance, among other things). This, I feel, constitutes a much stronger argument, because when comparing their teachings against Joseph Smith’s teachings, they are clearly wrong.
But at the end of the day, if you want to know whether a man is a prophet, a seer, and a revelator, you will be able to tell based on them doing the following things:
1. Exercising the gift of prophecy
2. Exercising the gift of seership
3. Exercising the gift of revelation
It’s just about as simple as that. Do the current leaders of the LDS Church show such fruit?
No, they do not.
Hence, no-one is bound to accept them as what they claim to be, because the fruit simply isn’t there.
People can perform all the mental gymnastics they want, but the current leaders do not display the actual fruits of actual prophets, actual seers, and actual revelators.
And let's assume for arguments sake that they do not in fact manifest these fruits at all, that would be a far cry from making false prophecies and working false miracles in the name of Christ.