The things we do for love

For discussion of liberty, freedom, government and politics.
Post Reply
User avatar
BuriedTartaria
Captain of Tartary
Posts: 1959

The things we do for love

Post by BuriedTartaria »

Over the past few years my religious beliefs have changed quite a bit in some ways and haven't changed much in others.

I believe in the Book of Mormon as a historic book of scripture more now than ever. I believe Joseph Smith was used as an instrument to translate the Book of Mormon more now than ever.

But I've fundamentally changed. I don't believe in institutional claims of leadership in the LDS faith. I sincerely find them to be blasphemous and this is a momentous difference from how I used to view things. And if you believe in those claims, I respect your view without sharing it and wish you the best in life.

I met a reformed prostitute today who went through the temple for the first time in her life a month or so ago. I told her I really respected and valued what she has done in her life that brought her to a situation like that and I showed a lot of sincere admiration as we talked. While on the inside I disagree and take offense to claims of authority from God and gifts of prophecy by the people behind the machine of all "that", I can set all of that aside and admire and respect someone who has put forth a lot of effort to draw closer to God in a way that heals her life and in a way that she finds meaningful.

I've thought a lot over the past few years about the re-thinking of the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith, authority claims, and Mormon-related history that many members of Restorationist churches are experiencing, particularly in the LDS faith. This affects connections (father and son, best friends, neighbors, mentors and mentees, etc) in a number of ways but can have a uniquely difficult strain on marriage when views change and differences perspectives on touchy matters arise.

So I've wondered a lot where that leaves me and so many others who are single, have a Mormon background, still believe in the Book of Mormon but just sincerely no longer believe in traditional LDS claims. I've reached the conclusion that no matter what, I and many others are just unlikely to ever find love in someone who shares all of our religious views and I need to learn to be okay with that.

I can be okay with that, but that's a hard sell for devout LDS, which is an audience that generally houses women I generally develop feelings for. I wouldn't want to pursue anyone in that house though because I have no deep desire to shatter a happy belief system that they have or potentially cause problems with their family.

There is someone I know in my life who really shows me how real of a challenge this is though. She's devout LDS. I've known her for like a year through work. I always thought she was just a pretty typical, cute LDS girl that I wouldn't have any interest in for a number of reasons (too typical, not enough of a free-thinker, the sort of girl who is looking to marry a future bishop, not my type and I'm not her type, she was anti-mask though)

I eventually realized I actually cared for her quite a bit and I believed there was nothing to do about it and nothing I could do about it and feeling like that is the situation of it all has really made me stew over it, like I'm trying to find some sort of solution. Rather than a woman finding value in my views of monogamous marriage, I'd be viewed as heretical for not co-signing the beauty of celestial plural marriage, it would be a source of contention. Rather than my commitment to the Book of Mormon being sincere and appreciated, the emphasis I place on it while condemning modern-day leadership of people claiming authority from the translator of it would be viewed as "anti-Mormon". Wouldn't I want the approval and affection of someone who finds value in my views rather than wanting it from someone who finds my views evil?

I really yearn to be understood by her but I'm afraid of what she'd think so I just don't know how to act. I saw her for the first time today that I've seen her in a few months. We were in a group and there was discussion going on. I know she'd hate me for my views so I try to keep myself at arms' length around her. I felt it would be best to just not really talk. So I tried to exit the situation without drawing attention to myself and as I walked away she told me it was nice to see me again. My heart broke at her kind effort to communicate and express appreciation and I turned back around and told her it was nice to see her. And I asked her for updates on all the stuff we'd talk about back when we saw each other more regularly.

I know my ship with her has sailed, but I can't deny how much I care about her, despite thinking she believes in a lot of lies. I see too many obstacles for us to ever workout, but I wish I could cut out as many of those obstacles as I could. I live temple standards aside from not paying tithing, but I don't have a temple recommend. She loves the temple. She has a certain one she has always wanted to get married in. I don't want a temple marriage, but if she felt half of what I felt for her and wanted to explore it, I'd get married in the temple for her.

Which brings me to the title of this topic, I want a current temple recommend to try and cut out an obstacle I see between us. I'm most likely going to be paying tithing to get a recommend back. Isn't that sad? Isn't that crazy? I'm engaging in what I see as building up a lie and I'm doing it because I wish I could remove deal-breaker barriers with someone I really care about and find special with no guarantee they like me beyond being a friend.

I've shown the Lord how weak my resolve is in taking a stand for what I deem to be right and worth fighting over. I feel so confused and weak. I don't see any clearly right options. Just choices with shades of grey to pick from.

User avatar
HereWeGo
captain of 1,000
Posts: 1299

Re: The things we do for love

Post by HereWeGo »

I work with a lot of inactive mormon guys. I think they are great guys. They still have most of their same habits and beliefs from when they were active. I have met some of their girlfriends who are in a similar situation. These girls are sweeties who still have religious leanings.

What I am saying is that if you only hang out with good LDS girls, your choices will be limited. An inactive girl could turn out to be a great match for you and would not be near as rejecting of your church opinions. Don't dismiss an inactive or less active girl but get to know her. She may well not be on your level and you can just move on. Then again, she may see your views and be easily accepting of where you are. She may even join you in your views.

User avatar
Sarah
Level 34 Illuminated
Posts: 6747

Re: The things we do for love

Post by Sarah »

Sounds like a budding romance for sure, but you are right to be worried. I know two couples close to me that have one active one not, and it's really hard on them, and can be heartbreaking for the active one. You shouldn't go to the temple unless you can acknowledge that this is the Lord's church on the earth, and you are ready to sacrifice your time and talents to serve in it, to help your fellow church members, and to support the church in fulfilling its different missions. Why? Because you are making sacred covenants with God, and God will not be mocked should you decide to disregard your promises.

User avatar
harakim
captain of 1,000
Posts: 2821
Location: Salt Lake Megalopolis

Re: The things we do for love

Post by harakim »

BuriedTartaria wrote: March 9th, 2022, 9:10 pm Over the past few years my religious beliefs have changed quite a bit in some ways and haven't changed much in others.

I believe in the Book of Mormon as a historic book of scripture more now than ever. I believe Joseph Smith was used as an instrument to translate the Book of Mormon more now than ever.

But I've fundamentally changed. I don't believe in institutional claims of leadership in the LDS faith. I sincerely find them to be blasphemous and this is a momentous difference from how I used to view things. And if you believe in those claims, I respect your view without sharing it and wish you the best in life.

I met a reformed prostitute today who went through the temple for the first time in her life a month or so ago. I told her I really respected and valued what she has done in her life that brought her to a situation like that and I showed a lot of sincere admiration as we talked. While on the inside I disagree and take offense to claims of authority from God and gifts of prophecy by the people behind the machine of all "that", I can set all of that aside and admire and respect someone who has put forth a lot of effort to draw closer to God in a way that heals her life and in a way that she finds meaningful.

I've thought a lot over the past few years about the re-thinking of the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith, authority claims, and Mormon-related history that many members of Restorationist churches are experiencing, particularly in the LDS faith. This affects connections (father and son, best friends, neighbors, mentors and mentees, etc) in a number of ways but can have a uniquely difficult strain on marriage when views change and differences perspectives on touchy matters arise.

So I've wondered a lot where that leaves me and so many others who are single, have a Mormon background, still believe in the Book of Mormon but just sincerely no longer believe in traditional LDS claims. I've reached the conclusion that no matter what, I and many others are just unlikely to ever find love in someone who shares all of our religious views and I need to learn to be okay with that.

I can be okay with that, but that's a hard sell for devout LDS, which is an audience that generally houses women I generally develop feelings for. I wouldn't want to pursue anyone in that house though because I have no deep desire to shatter a happy belief system that they have or potentially cause problems with their family.

There is someone I know in my life who really shows me how real of a challenge this is though. She's devout LDS. I've known her for like a year through work. I always thought she was just a pretty typical, cute LDS girl that I wouldn't have any interest in for a number of reasons (too typical, not enough of a free-thinker, the sort of girl who is looking to marry a future bishop, not my type and I'm not her type, she was anti-mask though)

I eventually realized I actually cared for her quite a bit and I believed there was nothing to do about it and nothing I could do about it and feeling like that is the situation of it all has really made me stew over it, like I'm trying to find some sort of solution. Rather than a woman finding value in my views of monogamous marriage, I'd be viewed as heretical for not co-signing the beauty of celestial plural marriage, it would be a source of contention. Rather than my commitment to the Book of Mormon being sincere and appreciated, the emphasis I place on it while condemning modern-day leadership of people claiming authority from the translator of it would be viewed as "anti-Mormon". Wouldn't I want the approval and affection of someone who finds value in my views rather than wanting it from someone who finds my views evil?

I really yearn to be understood by her but I'm afraid of what she'd think so I just don't know how to act. I saw her for the first time today that I've seen her in a few months. We were in a group and there was discussion going on. I know she'd hate me for my views so I try to keep myself at arms' length around her. I felt it would be best to just not really talk. So I tried to exit the situation without drawing attention to myself and as I walked away she told me it was nice to see me again. My heart broke at her kind effort to communicate and express appreciation and I turned back around and told her it was nice to see her. And I asked her for updates on all the stuff we'd talk about back when we saw each other more regularly.

I know my ship with her has sailed, but I can't deny how much I care about her, despite thinking she believes in a lot of lies. I see too many obstacles for us to ever workout, but I wish I could cut out as many of those obstacles as I could. I live temple standards aside from not paying tithing, but I don't have a temple recommend. She loves the temple. She has a certain one she has always wanted to get married in. I don't want a temple marriage, but if she felt half of what I felt for her and wanted to explore it, I'd get married in the temple for her.

Which brings me to the title of this topic, I want a current temple recommend to try and cut out an obstacle I see between us. I'm most likely going to be paying tithing to get a recommend back. Isn't that sad? Isn't that crazy? I'm engaging in what I see as building up a lie and I'm doing it because I wish I could remove deal-breaker barriers with someone I really care about and find special with no guarantee they like me beyond being a friend.

I've shown the Lord how weak my resolve is in taking a stand for what I deem to be right and worth fighting over. I feel so confused and weak. I don't see any clearly right options. Just choices with shades of grey to pick from.
You have to be bold and be yourself. You have to put yourself out there and risk get rejected. Just tell her you like her. What's the worst that can happen? She rejects you? Well, you already have rejected her so it's never going to work out anyway, right? When you find yourself, you'll be able to find a girl.

User avatar
Fred
Level 34 Illuminated
Posts: 7925
Location: Zion

Re: The things we do for love

Post by Fred »

Whether or not a girl is LDS is not nearly as important as your feelings for each other and how you get along. I met a girl in rehab 22 years ago and she was Catholic. We left rehab together and my Bishop strongly recommended that we get married. I figured that the chances of her changing religions was about a million to one. It is not easy to get someone to change their religion. She agreed to listen to the missionaries. I would have listened to hers. It is simply a matter of seeking truth, wherever it is. The Bishop invited us to his home where the missionaries came to make their presentations. After the first visit, I never saw her read any of the material and for sure not the Book of Mormon. So on the second visit when the missionaries asked her about Nephi and his brothers, she had read all about it and was intrigued. I was shocked. I had no idea she was even interested. We never talked about it. I did not want to put any pressure on her and just let the missionaries do their job. She read the whole BoM and was baptized. Something happens when people find truth.

As far as tithing goes, it is only money. It's not like you have to cut off a finger. God sees what you are doing and why. That is all that counts. Ordinances are subject to God's approval, no matter who does them so I wouldn't worry about that either. You did what you thought was right. God honors it.

Just make sure that you are the person that you need to be to attract the person you want. You never know who is watching. It can surprise you.

Good luck!

User avatar
BuriedTartaria
Captain of Tartary
Posts: 1959

Re: The things we do for love

Post by BuriedTartaria »

harakim wrote: March 9th, 2022, 10:10 pm You have to be bold and be yourself. You have to put yourself out there and risk get rejected. Just tell her you like her. What's the worst that can happen? She rejects you? Well, you already have rejected her so it's never going to work out anyway, right? When you find yourself, you'll be able to find a girl.
Wow, this reply cuts deep. And it cuts because it's the truth. I have rejected her and written her off. You're right. And while I wouldn't say I need to find myself (I think know myself), I would say I need to find where I belong or find how I fit. I need to just be humble enough to accept being rejected.


Other people have given me thoughts and advice in this thread and I'm going to reply to them, just not tonight. I don't feel well tonight. Your post just cut me and I needed to thank you for it. Thanks for your time and advice

Post Reply