oneClimbs wrote: ↑August 14th, 2019, 10:28 am
What if it is not about health?
BIngo! Thank you!
The Word of Wisdom is not a law of health, it is a law of obedience. I'm going to go on a stretch and say to ignore any more recent publication that bills it as a "code of health", because it's wrong. That's okay. PR and manual writers get small details wrong once in a while.
The Word of Wisdom was given as a well-followed suggestion by a prophet of God, and later codified into a hardline commandment by a prophet of God. It is clear that it is not a code of health, because you can be generally healthy despite not following it, and you can be generally unhealthy despite living it to the letter.
When Christ was asked what the commandments were, He listed only two: "Love God" and "Love everyone else". The Ten Commandments, as an example, are merely an expansion of those two, a sort of "alright dummy, this is what I mean when I say it". The Word of Wisdom is much like this. By the letter, caffeine is not against the Word of Wisdom. Does your journey to become obedient to God involve simply drinking anything with caffeine in it that isn't tea or coffee? It ought to rather cause you to stop and suppose "If I want to avoid addictive substances of any kind, maybe I should avoid caffeine, despite being able to consume it and still attend the temple?"
Remember, obedience, not health. If you think _____ tea is good for you and you promise to follow a command not to drink something produced from the tea, that includes _____ tea no matter what part of the plant or its age, end of story. That is probably why it is disqualifying for temple admittance-it's about your lying as much or more than it is the naked act of drinking tea. If I promise the Lord on His condition for remitting my sins that I will never cut my hair or eat grapes, no arguments about the health benefit of grapes or the social expectation of men having short hair will get in the way of that.
Medical use? I strongly doubt the idea that there is anything in the world that marijuana works best on or that only marijuana works on. Besides that, it's worth looking at in this context: How much faith do I have to live a law I've promised to live despite hardship, and what is the nature of the hardship? Am I literally non-functional without a caffeine supplement? Can
nothing but marajuana manage the feelings of this pain, and am I absolutely sure without lying to myself that I loathe the thought of simply being "baked"? And if I am appropriately opposed to the idea of altering my capacity to think and make decisions, wouldn't I be trying harder to find an alternative? Two of my immediate family members growing up are addicted to powerful painkillers whose recreational use would be WAY outside temple worthiness, or even just not-being-in-jail. They manage their pain, but the other effects of painkillers-as well as the pain of not having them and the kind of desperation it generates-have done enough damage to our immediate and extended family that maybe it isn't worth it if their resolves are to "come unto Christ". It's not as if they're doing anything else right in regards to their health, anyway, which leads to the painful thought of "how much is actually their fault after years of self-neglect?"
I want to further understand the Gospel and Celestial life. I want to know the "deeper mysteries". I can't be successful in my attempt to seek these things if there is anything at all I've already been given and seek to skirt around, rather than exemplify and expand.
I am no one's bishop, but this is my take:
- Tea is against the Word of Wisdom. That includes green tea, white tea, or whatever else, no matter how delicious green tea ice cream is. The part of the plant you use or the plant's age are irrelevant.
- Coffee is against the Word of Wisdom, caffeine is not (by the letter). This means that decaf is not okay, because it is still coffee.
- Caffeine itself is not, by the letter, against the Word of Wisdom. Nevertheless, I don't want or need it.
- Strong drinks-alcoholic drinks-are against the Word of Wisdom. That includes beer today, whatever the expectation was in times past.
- Smoking tobacco is against the Word of Wisdom. Easy.
- Before this statement against vaping, I would not ever sit and think "Well it's not tobacco, so it's probably okay." It's probably not a hot idea to breathe
anything but good air.
- Caffeine is not against the Word of Wisdom, but maybe it should be. I don't want or need it.
- "Recreational" and illegal drugs are listed today not to partake of, the reasons are obvious. Even If marijuana use didn't disqualify one from the temple, I don't want or need any part of it.
- DO eat basically the food pyramid. Give special attention to meat in particular, recognizing the sacredness of the life lost in providing it.
- DO use wholesome food and herbs to maintain your body, having faith in healing and in the priesthood.
- Exercise, by the letter, is not a part of the Word of Wisdom. It's certainly a really good idea, though. It is, directly or indirectly, the easiest fix to almost every health problem anyone in my family has, and I suspect generally as a population. And I don't mean a one mile jog at Planet Fitness during their pizza night. Our bodies are temples, and when they build temples, they don't just throw up some granite on a patch of dirt and call it good, they build and maintain a very strong foundation.