Re: Rumor WOW change?
Posted: March 14th, 2019, 4:16 pm
Take this thinking exercise with me for a moment.
tobacco = tobacco
wholesome herbs and fruits = wholesome herbs and fruits
flesh of beasts = flesh of beasts
grain = grain
corn = corn
oats = oats
rye = rye
barley = barley
wine and strong drink = wine and strong drink (alcohol)
hot drinks = coffee and tea?
One of these things is not like the others. Well, two actually. It seems strange to me that the Lord lists things explicitly, and then we interpret in a way that doesn't match the specific word with its most obvious definition. Even in the 1830s, the most basic and obvious definition of "hot" was hot in temperature. It's not as if the Lord and Joseph were unaware of the words "coffee" and "tea."
The second thing is "wine and strong drink." This, to me, is a reference to strong wines and liquors, not mild fermented drinks like beers and ales homemade wines. There is a "prohibition" against drunkenness in the scriptures, but not against mild drinks. In other words, it seems to me that the Lord here is saying it isn't wise to drink to drunkenness, and that wine and strong drink are specifically mentioned because of how little you have to drink to get drunk; but, he then explicitly says when it is wise to make and use wine. "Wine of your own make" IS alcoholic. The yeast on the skins and stems and/or in the air is sufficient to ferment homegrown grapes. Smashing the grapes, breaking the skin, exposes the juice to the yeast and creates one condition necessary for the sugar to be converted to alcohol. Therefore, if you're making wine of your own make, it is generally going to have some percentage of alcohol, depending on how quickly it is consumed.
And why doesn't hot drinks mean hot, as in temperature...as in, "Hey guys, don't burn your mouth or your body with hot liquid, because it's not good for you!"? I believe that's exactly what it means, and they associated it with coffee and tea because both were typically consumed at a hot temperature.
My opinion is that there will be a WoW restoration at some point, whether sooner or later, and that drunkenness will be "condemned" while mild drinks are considered a moderation thing, and that "hot drinks" will mean "hot drinks," as in "hot temperature." In addition, I believe it will again be considered a word of wisdom and principle with a promise and not mandatory for baptism or ordinances. And, yes, I would be delighted if we started using real church-made wine for the sacrament instead of water.
I'll obey the word to the wise as presently interpreted, and I encourage everyone else to do so as well. But I do believe it will eventually be restored to its original state as revealed to Joseph Smith.
tobacco = tobacco
wholesome herbs and fruits = wholesome herbs and fruits
flesh of beasts = flesh of beasts
grain = grain
corn = corn
oats = oats
rye = rye
barley = barley
wine and strong drink = wine and strong drink (alcohol)
hot drinks = coffee and tea?
One of these things is not like the others. Well, two actually. It seems strange to me that the Lord lists things explicitly, and then we interpret in a way that doesn't match the specific word with its most obvious definition. Even in the 1830s, the most basic and obvious definition of "hot" was hot in temperature. It's not as if the Lord and Joseph were unaware of the words "coffee" and "tea."
The second thing is "wine and strong drink." This, to me, is a reference to strong wines and liquors, not mild fermented drinks like beers and ales homemade wines. There is a "prohibition" against drunkenness in the scriptures, but not against mild drinks. In other words, it seems to me that the Lord here is saying it isn't wise to drink to drunkenness, and that wine and strong drink are specifically mentioned because of how little you have to drink to get drunk; but, he then explicitly says when it is wise to make and use wine. "Wine of your own make" IS alcoholic. The yeast on the skins and stems and/or in the air is sufficient to ferment homegrown grapes. Smashing the grapes, breaking the skin, exposes the juice to the yeast and creates one condition necessary for the sugar to be converted to alcohol. Therefore, if you're making wine of your own make, it is generally going to have some percentage of alcohol, depending on how quickly it is consumed.
And why doesn't hot drinks mean hot, as in temperature...as in, "Hey guys, don't burn your mouth or your body with hot liquid, because it's not good for you!"? I believe that's exactly what it means, and they associated it with coffee and tea because both were typically consumed at a hot temperature.
My opinion is that there will be a WoW restoration at some point, whether sooner or later, and that drunkenness will be "condemned" while mild drinks are considered a moderation thing, and that "hot drinks" will mean "hot drinks," as in "hot temperature." In addition, I believe it will again be considered a word of wisdom and principle with a promise and not mandatory for baptism or ordinances. And, yes, I would be delighted if we started using real church-made wine for the sacrament instead of water.
I'll obey the word to the wise as presently interpreted, and I encourage everyone else to do so as well. But I do believe it will eventually be restored to its original state as revealed to Joseph Smith.