Page 1 of 5
What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:19 pm
by Jonesy
No need to specify with a comment. Just a pulse of the members of LDSFF.
Let me know if there needs to be another option.
ANSWER CAN BE CHANGED
Edit: Changed answer ‘A’ from “TBM; believe that church and leaders have keys. We are moving in the right direction as directed by Christ.” to “Member of church; believe that church and leaders have keys. Believe that the 15 are true apostles or prophets of God, or at least Pres. Nelson is a true prophet of God.”
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:21 pm
by Elizabeth
I do not identify as Mormon.
I identify as LDS, Latter-day Saint, Christian, or a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:28 pm
by Finrock
Elizabeth wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 2:21 pm
I do not identify as Mormon.
I identify as LDS, Latter-day Saint, Christian, or a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
That's like saying: "I don't identify as a human. I identify as Homo sapiens sapiens."
-Finrock
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:29 pm
by gardener4life
Ohhh polls are fun. It will be interesting to see how it turns out.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:40 pm
by PressingForward
I chose B as it was closest to my belief. Although I believe Apostles and Prophets are such when acting in the name of the Lord, it is more than just a title. They are imperfect men, as we have examples in the past of poor actions on their part. This does not change the gospel of Jesus Christ, nor heavenly fathers plan at all.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 2:57 pm
by lundbaek
I believe that the LDS Church and the leaders have keys. However, we are not moving in all the right directions as directed by Christ.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 3:12 pm
by Chip
Yay!!! I'm in the majority!
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 3:15 pm
by DesertWonderer2
A.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 3:15 pm
by David13
I'm the good kind.
Right on the corner, and right on the price.
Poor but honest.
Sit in the same seat every Sunday.
dc
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 3:36 pm
by Finrock
TBM: believe that church and leaders have keys. The Church is fulfilling its role and functioning as intended and in many ways moving in the right direction. believes that members and leaders alike are fallible and accepts all that this implies. believes that "prophet" and "apostle" CAN be just a title, but, also believes that there are true prophets and true apostles of Jesus Christ leading the Church or within the Church.
-Finrock
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 3:40 pm
by Durzan
Can you put in an "other" option? None of the current options accurately describe my views. If I HAD to choose between the options presented currently, I'd say my view aligns closer with Option B.
I would consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I am a Member of the LDS Church, I believe the church and leaders have the keys of the priesthood, and are authorized by the Lord to direct the church. I believe that the Leaders of the Church are often inspired of God, but are fallible in nature, and as such can make mistakes big or small. I believe that the Lord allows the leaders of the Church to rely on their own judgement at least to some reasonable extent, and that not all church policies are necessarily guided by the Spirit or inspired (that doesn't mean they are not though).
I believe that the Church is currently under condemnation, and that as part of that condemnation, major divine revelation and miracles have largely been reduced to a trickle within the Church and are being withheld by the Lord. I believe that such condemnation is largely due to pride, stubbornness, corruption, and unrighteousness among the general membership; that the saints of the church, as a people, are not currently seeking to faithfully uphold their covenants, but instead have their hearts set upon the things of this world. Because of this unrighteousness, the Lord has commanded his servants to withhold the records of any revelation containing additional laws, mysteries, principles, and so forth, until such a time when the general membership fully repent and seek to faithfully uphold their covenants.
I believe that we, as a people, are not necessarily moving in "...all the right directions as directed by Christ," as Lunbaek put it. I believe that the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel were promised to remain upon the earth, but not necessarily the Church itself insofar as it is an official and highly organized religious institution. I belief that statements that would indicate otherwise are the personal opinions of the individual, and not actual doctrine, though such is often construed as such. I believe that a full Apostasy within the church is possible (but not necessarily probable), and that the Lord has established mechanisms to preserve the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel should this happen, or should all 15 Apostles and Prophets meet a sudden and untimely end without being able to appoint and ordain successors. Nevertheless, I believe that the Lord will fight tooth and nail to preserve the church, would go to just about any lengths to preserve it, and would only activate the emergency mechanisms He established as an absolute last resort to preserve both the priesthood and the gospel.
I believe there is some level and form of corporate corruption and secret combinations imbedded within the bowls of the church bureaucracy, but that the most members of the Seventy, the Presiding Bishopric, the Apostles, and First Presidency remain mostly innocent of it. I believe that it is possible (however unlikely), for an apostle or prophet to become corrupted, and for such corruption to potentially cause grave damage to the church and its members. Nevertheless, it is my impression that the current Apostles and Prophets now established as leaders of the church are largely good, honorable and inspired men who are in tune with the spirit. However, I believe that the strong spiritual connection the General Authorities have with God has for the most part waned in strength since the days of Joseph Smith, due to the church being under condemnation, as well as the rising level of corruption within church bureaucracy.
I believe that some doctrines may have been changed, altered, or suppressed by church leadership in times past and may need to be reexamined and/or restored on a case by case basis. Yet this should be done by and through inspiration of the Spirit, and approved by proper priesthood authority. This is why I consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I believe that God ultimately has control over how everything plays out, at least up to the extent that doesn't directly interfere with Mankind's agency. I believe that scriptures and the prophecies contained within have multiple interpretations, references, meanings, and layers to them; that said scriptures may not have originally intended to have the context we currently associate with them, either officially or unofficially; and that as such, the Lord could mean something entirely different from that which we teach. Nevertheless, the official interpretation(s) of religious literature still has much value, insofar as they are inspired and confirmed by the spirit.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 4:24 pm
by LukeAir2008
Elizabeth wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 2:21 pm
I do not identify as Mormon.
I identify as LDS, Latter-day Saint, Christian, or a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Good point. ‘Mormon’ describes any group, church or movement that traces their origins back to Joseph Smith.
And there are many.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 4:44 pm
by Jonesy
Durzan wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 3:40 pm
Can you put in an "other" option? None of the current options accurately describe my views. If I HAD to choose between the options presented currently, I'd say my view aligns closer with Option B.
I would consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I am a Member of the LDS Church, I believe the church and leaders have the keys of the priesthood, and are authorized by the Lord to direct the church. I believe that the Leaders of the Church are often inspired of God, but are fallible in nature, and as such can make mistakes big or small. I believe that the Lord allows the leaders of the Church to rely on their own judgement at least to some reasonable extent, and that not all church policies are necessarily guided by the Spirit or inspired (that doesn't mean they are not though).
I believe that the Church is currently under condemnation, and that as part of that condemnation, major divine revelation and miracles have largely been reduced to a trickle within the Church and are being withheld by the Lord. I believe that such condemnation is largely due to pride, stubbornness, corruption, and unrighteousness among the general membership; that the saints of the church, as a people, are not currently seeking to faithfully uphold their covenants, but instead have their hearts set upon the things of this world. Because of this unrighteousness, the Lord has commanded his servants to withhold the records of any revelation containing additional laws, mysteries, principles, and so forth, until such a time when the general membership fully repent and seek to faithfully uphold their covenants.
I believe that we, as a people, are not necessarily moving in "...all the right directions as directed by Christ," as Lunbaek put it. I believe that the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel were promised to remain upon the earth, but not necessarily the Church itself insofar as it is an official and highly organized religious institution. I belief that statements that would indicate otherwise are the personal opinions of the individual, and not actual doctrine, though such is often construed as such. I believe that a full Apostasy within the church is possible (but not necessarily probable), and that the Lord has established mechanisms to preserve the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel should this happen, or should all 15 Apostles and Prophets meet a sudden and untimely end without being able to appoint and ordain successors. Nevertheless, I believe that the Lord will fight tooth and nail to preserve the church, would go to just about any lengths to preserve it, and would only activate the emergency mechanisms He established as an absolute last resort to preserve both the priesthood and the gospel.
I believe there is some level and form of corporate corruption and secret combinations imbedded within the bowls of the church bureaucracy,
but that the most members of the Seventy, the Presiding Bishopric, the Apostles, and First Presidency remain mostly innocent of it. I believe that it is possible (however unlikely), for an apostle or prophet to become corrupted, and for such corruption to potentially cause grave damage to the church and its members. Nevertheless, it is my impression that the current Apostles and Prophets now established as leaders of the church are largely good, honorable and inspired men who are in tune with the spirit. However, I believe that the strong spiritual connection the General Authorities have with God has for the most part waned in strength since the days of Joseph Smith, due to the church being under condemnation, as well as the rising level of corruption within church bureaucracy.
I believe that some doctrines may have been changed, altered, or suppressed by church leadership in times past and may need to be reexamined and/or restored on a case by case basis. Yet this should be done by and through inspiration of the Spirit, and approved by proper priesthood authority. This is why I consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I believe that God ultimately has control over how everything plays out, at least up to the extent that doesn't directly interfere with Mankind's agency. I believe that scriptures and the prophecies contained within have multiple interpretations, references, meanings, and layers to them; that said scriptures may not have originally intended to have the context we currently associate with them, either officially or unofficially; and that as such, the Lord could mean something entirely different from that which we teach. Nevertheless, the official interpretation(s) of religious literature still has much value, insofar as they are inspired and confirmed by the spirit.
A Reformationist Mormon? Never heard of it. Did you make this up? Did you mean restorationist (I guess all Mormons are)? Or do you mean Reformationist, as in you advocate reform in the LDS Church?
If you believe that the 15 are actual prophets of God (or at least Pres. Nelson), then I would put ‘A’. Otherwise, I would just choose ‘B’. I think everyone can say they have varied beliefs, but can nail it down to either options.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 4:56 pm
by Finrock
Jonesy wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 4:44 pm
If you believe that the 15 are actual prophets of God (or at least Pres. Nelson), then I would put ‘A’. Otherwise, I would just choose ‘B’. I think everyone can say they have varied beliefs, but can nail it down to either options.
No, they can't be nailed down to either A or B. Your options are not representative. That is why you are being asked to include "Other". Also, your poll seems biased. Option A is not solely (or even reliably) indicative of a TBM. If you truly want to get a pulse of the forum, your poll needs to be representative of your target audience or group (in this case LDSFF participants).
-Finrock
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:25 pm
by Durzan
Jonesy wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 4:44 pm
Durzan wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 3:40 pm
Can you put in an "other" option? None of the current options accurately describe my views. If I HAD to choose between the options presented currently, I'd say my view aligns closer with Option B.
I would consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I am a Member of the LDS Church, I believe the church and leaders have the keys of the priesthood, and are authorized by the Lord to direct the church. I believe that the Leaders of the Church are often inspired of God, but are fallible in nature, and as such can make mistakes big or small. I believe that the Lord allows the leaders of the Church to rely on their own judgement at least to some reasonable extent, and that not all church policies are necessarily guided by the Spirit or inspired (that doesn't mean they are not though).
I believe that the Church is currently under condemnation, and that as part of that condemnation, major divine revelation and miracles have largely been reduced to a trickle within the Church and are being withheld by the Lord. I believe that such condemnation is largely due to pride, stubbornness, corruption, and unrighteousness among the general membership; that the saints of the church, as a people, are not currently seeking to faithfully uphold their covenants, but instead have their hearts set upon the things of this world. Because of this unrighteousness, the Lord has commanded his servants to withhold the records of any revelation containing additional laws, mysteries, principles, and so forth, until such a time when the general membership fully repent and seek to faithfully uphold their covenants.
I believe that we, as a people, are not necessarily moving in "...all the right directions as directed by Christ," as Lunbaek put it. I believe that the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel were promised to remain upon the earth, but not necessarily the Church itself insofar as it is an official and highly organized religious institution. I belief that statements that would indicate otherwise are the personal opinions of the individual, and not actual doctrine, though such is often construed as such. I believe that a full Apostasy within the church is possible (but not necessarily probable), and that the Lord has established mechanisms to preserve the Priesthood and the teachings of the Gospel should this happen, or should all 15 Apostles and Prophets meet a sudden and untimely end without being able to appoint and ordain successors. Nevertheless, I believe that the Lord will fight tooth and nail to preserve the church, would go to just about any lengths to preserve it, and would only activate the emergency mechanisms He established as an absolute last resort to preserve both the priesthood and the gospel.
I believe there is some level and form of corporate corruption and secret combinations imbedded within the bowls of the church bureaucracy,
but that the most members of the Seventy, the Presiding Bishopric, the Apostles, and First Presidency remain mostly innocent of it. I believe that it is possible (however unlikely), for an apostle or prophet to become corrupted, and for such corruption to potentially cause grave damage to the church and its members. Nevertheless, it is my impression that the current Apostles and Prophets now established as leaders of the church are largely good, honorable and inspired men who are in tune with the spirit. However, I believe that the strong spiritual connection the General Authorities have with God has for the most part waned in strength since the days of Joseph Smith, due to the church being under condemnation, as well as the rising level of corruption within church bureaucracy.
I believe that some doctrines may have been changed, altered, or suppressed by church leadership in times past and may need to be reexamined and/or restored on a case by case basis. Yet this should be done by and through inspiration of the Spirit, and approved by proper priesthood authority. This is why I consider myself a Reformationist Mormon.
I believe that God ultimately has control over how everything plays out, at least up to the extent that doesn't directly interfere with Mankind's agency. I believe that scriptures and the prophecies contained within have multiple interpretations, references, meanings, and layers to them; that said scriptures may not have originally intended to have the context we currently associate with them, either officially or unofficially; and that as such, the Lord could mean something entirely different from that which we teach. Nevertheless, the official interpretation(s) of religious literature still has much value, insofar as they are inspired and confirmed by the spirit.
A Reformationist Mormon? Never heard of it. Did you make this up? Did you mean restorationist (I guess all Mormons are)? Or do you mean Reformationist, as in you advocate reform in the LDS Church?
If you believe that the 15 are actual prophets of God (or at least Pres. Nelson), then I would put ‘A’. Otherwise, I would just choose ‘B’. I think everyone can say they have varied beliefs, but can nail it down to either options.
Reformationist as in advocating reform within the Church... just like you had the Catholic Reformation as a counterpoint to the Protestant split.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:27 pm
by Jonesy
Finrock wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 4:56 pm
Jonesy wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 4:44 pm
If you believe that the 15 are actual prophets of God (or at least Pres. Nelson), then I would put ‘A’. Otherwise, I would just choose ‘B’. I think everyone can say they have varied beliefs, but can nail it down to either options.
No, they can't be nailed down to either A or B. Your options are not representative. That is why you are being asked to include "Other". Also, your poll seems biased. Option A is not solely (or even reliably) indicative of a TBM. If you truly want to get a pulse of the forum, your poll needs to be representative of your target audience or group (in this case LDSFF participants).
-Finrock
I’m open to suggestions. How would you break it down?
I made the poll so you can change your answer, as well.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:35 pm
by Jonesy
Durzan wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 5:25 pm
Reformationist as in advocating reform within the Church... just like you had the Catholic Reformation as a counterpoint to the Protestant split.
Gotcha. Then I think you fall in to ‘B’. My reason is that if you believed that the leaders were actually prophets (‘A’), then a reform wouldn’t be needed because they are being guided how it should be guided. With option B, You may believe it is still guided by inspiration and/or you may believe reform is needed or will come.
However, do you have a reasonable breakdown for another option?
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:41 pm
by lundbaek
I believe that the LDS Church and the leaders have keys. However, we are not moving in all the right directions as directed by Christ. I guess that's between A & B. I maintain that we are not moving in all the right directions as directed by Christ because I note there are commandments and admonitions directed at us in the scriptures and in the words of latter-day prophets and apostles that are being ignored by members of the Church.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:48 pm
by Jonesy
Made an edit. See original post. Hopefully this will clear things up.
Still open to suggestions.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:51 pm
by Jesef
Yeah, I think the poll was obviously written by someone in the (A) category, because it is very myopic on the issues. You keep mentioning "keys" and "apostasy" as your defining criteria. It's written from a very Utah-homogenous-ultra-orthodox perspective. There's way more categories of members.
How about a category that's more along the lines of putting Mormonism/LDS-ism into a universal context (all human beings & all human history), a heterodox category, such as: believe in living all the standards, believe many of the truths, but believe many things may not ultimately mean what we think they mean, i.e. there are many possibilities and not everything has been revealed.
Or do you just want people to weigh in on: Follow the Prophets, They have the only True Priesthood Keys (Only True & Living Church), and we are NOT in Apostasy (we have not gone astray and have not lost Divine Favor or Authorization)?
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:55 pm
by Durzan
Jonesy wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 5:35 pm
Durzan wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 5:25 pm
Reformationist as in advocating reform within the Church... just like you had the Catholic Reformation as a counterpoint to the Protestant split.
Gotcha. Then I think you fall in to ‘B’. My reason is that if you believed that the leaders were actually prophets (‘A’), then a reform wouldn’t be needed because they are being guided how it should be guided. With option B, You may believe it is still guided by inspiration and/or you may believe reform is needed or will come.
However, do you have a reasonable breakdown for another option?
Eh, I still view them as prophets. Prophets are still men, even when being guided by the Spirit, and sometimes even the most spiritual person can miss or suppress instructions and impressions given by the spirit, or misinterpret it, etc. IE They can still make major mistakes in my book. Joseph Smith and Brigham Young each had plenty of faults, and made plenty of mistakes in regards to the Church. Doesn't mean that they are not prophets or that I'd stop supporting them if they royally screw up.
I admit that there does seem to be a significant difference in power between some of the earlier Prophets and Apostles compared to nowadays, but I established that that is due to the church still being under condemnation rather than the current church leaders not being prophets. Prophets are inspired men.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 5:57 pm
by Jonesy
Jesef wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 5:51 pm
Yeah, I think the poll was obviously written by someone in the (A) category, because it is very myopic on the issues. You keep mentioning "keys" and "apostasy" as your defining criteria. It's written from a very Utah-homogenous-ultra-orthodox perspective. There's way more categories of members.
How about a category that's more along the lines of putting Mormonism/LDS-ism into a universal context (all human beings & all human history), a heterodox category, such as: believe in living all the standards, believe many of the truths, but believe many things may not ultimately mean what we think they mean, i.e. there are many possibilities and not everything has been revealed.
Or do you just want people to weigh in on: Follow the Prophets, They have the only True Priesthood Keys (Only True & Living Church), and we are NOT in Apostasy (we have not gone astray and have not lost Divine Favor or Authorization)?
Any suggestions? Or you can make up your own poll.
Admittedly, I chose B.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 6:17 pm
by Jesef
See I would vote (A) with the following explanations:
> Member of church: YES
> Believe that church and leaders have keys: YES, but what do you mean by "keys", how would you define that? We might define it differently. I don't think the keys mean what many people think or believe they do. If you mean, "the authority to direct how Priesthood Authority is used in the Church", which includes directing how/who/when/what Priesthood ordinances are performed, callings, organization, etc. Then YES. Do these keys apply to the whole world? Probably not in the way most LDS think. They really don't affect most of the people in the world or most of world history even.
> Believe that 15 are true apostles or prophets of God, or at least Pres. Nelson is a true prophet of God: YES, but again, we might have different definitions of the scope and actual significance of what these titles/positions/callings mean in the grand scheme of things. You may think this is a big game of Follow the Leader/Prophet and that your eternal salvation depends on how closely and diligently you follow the living men filling these roles. You may believe that "Prophet" is akin to representative of God - like the way you treat the Prophet is the way God considers you treating God. If so, I believe you are overestimating their value or significance. I believe Prophets means Teachers, Servants of God, not Rulers, Masters, Demi-Gods - I don't believe they need to be venerated or worshipped or kowtowed to, stood for, hailed, praised, or testified of as if they are anything more than inspired humans. They don't have super-powers or super-spiritual gifts. I think we've gone WAY overboard in our prophet-worship in this Church. It's borderline ridiculous. No wonder the Brethren can't live up to these fantastic expectations. They aren't visiting with Jesus or heavenly angels every week, or going around healing the sick or raising the dead or working miracles. None that I've seen my whole 40+ years in the Church.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 6:27 pm
by Jonesy
Yeah, that’s why I’m okay with people determining what their own beliefs are. They can interpret them the way they’d like.
Re: What Kind of Mormon are You?
Posted: June 27th, 2018, 7:30 pm
by Finrock
LukeAir2008 wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 4:24 pm
Elizabeth wrote: ↑June 27th, 2018, 2:21 pm
I do not identify as Mormon.
I identify as LDS, Latter-day Saint, Christian, or a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Good point. ‘Mormon’ describes any group, church or movement that traces their origins back to Joseph Smith.
And there are many.
Actually, Mormon is used almost exclusively to designate members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.
Now, the word christian describes any christian group, church, or movement that advocates the teachings of Jesus Christ.
-Finrock