Page 5 of 19
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:03 am
by AGStacker
Robin Hood wrote:I will say this.
If the church ever embraces gay marriage, or recognizes "married" gays as equal to heterosexual marrieds, or accepts practicing gays as members in good standing, I will be out the door as fast as my legs can carry me. And I won't look back.
They will. The Church's main money source is from older, white conservative Mormons. They don't ever want revenues to decrease. (what organization does?) Therefore they will have to slowly, but surely, open up to those Mormons, and would be Mormons, who are growing up more liberal because of the growth of government and its greater influence on the people as a whole.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:08 am
by briznian
samizdat wrote:Elder Oaks has always been against gay marriage. If you are trying to suggest that the October 2014 Conference talk that he gave about civility is a tacit approval of gay marriage then you are surely mistaken.

Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:15 am
by AGStacker
BenMcCrea wrote:Joseph Smith said:
No true angel from God will ever come to ordain any man, because they have once been sent to establish the priesthood by ordaining me thereunto;…the priesthood once being established on earth, with power to ordain others, no heavenly messenger will ever come to interfere with that power by ordaining any more…You may therefore know, from this time forward, that if any man comes to you professing to be ordained by an angel, he is either a liar or has been imposed upon in consequence of transgression by an angel of the devil for this priesthood shall never be taken away from this church. (Millenial Star, 20 Nov. 1846, p.139, underline added)
Full quote gives a better understanding:
Brother Joseph observed to (Francis G. who claimed he had received an ordination by an Angel) Bishop that he knew he had lied before he confessed it; that his declarations were not only false in themselves, but they involved a false principle. An angel, said Joseph, may administer the word of the Lord unto men, and bring intelligence to them from heaven upon various subjects; but no true angel from God will ever come to ordain any man, because they have once been sent to establish the priesthood by ordaining me thereunto; and the priesthood being once established on earth with power to ordain others, no heavenly messenger will ever come to interfere with that power by ordaining any more. He referred to the angel that came to Cornelius and told Cornelius to send for Peter; but if there had been no Peter with keys and power to administer, the angel might have done it himself; but as there was, the angel would not interfere. Saul was directed to go to Ananias for instruction and to be administered to by him; but if there had been no Ananias with power and authority on the earth to administer in the name of Christ, the Lord might have done it himself. You may therefore know, from this time forward, that if any man comes to you professing to be ordained by angel, he is either a liar or has been imposed upon in consequence of transgression by an angel of the devil, for this priesthood shall never be taken away from this church.
This testimony was delivered in an upper room, in the south-west corner of the White Store and dwelling-house, formerly occupied by Whitney and Gilbert, situate on Kirtland Flats.
If men would regard the testimony of the servants of God who have laid down their lives for the cause, they would have little to fear of being misled; but when the spirit of apostasy takes possession of a man’s heart, he becomes completely blind to every true principle, and is filled with strife, debate, deceit, false accusation, and treachery. He cherishes no desire to convert and save the world, but is content to confine his operations to the church, which he slanders, defames, and, like a ravening wolf, tries to tear in pieces and destroy; and having no merit of his own to bring him into notice, he seeks to obtain notoriety by contention and debate, which the Lord declares are not of him but of the devil. Their hearts being a fountain of evil, they can speak nothing but evil; they, being disciples of the “accuser of our brethren,” can do nothing but accuse the brethren like their master whom they serve; they having a beam in their own eye, can see nothing but the mote in their brother’s eye; and well did the Saviour ask such characters, “how can ye, being evil, speak good things?“ They are like the filthy and indelicate bird that has no relish for sweet and wholesome meat, but likes to feast on tainted flesh and putrid carcasses. (Millennial Star, 20 Nov. 1846, 139, Elder Orson Hyde referencing a principle elucidated by Joseph Smith in the School of the Prophets. retrieved June, 2014 from:
http://contentdm.lib.byu.edu/cdm/compou" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false; ... /973/rec/2 )
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:18 am
by AGStacker
Joseph was ordained and given the power or charge to ordain others. So no need to receive an ordination from an angel when the power to ordain was on Earth. Ordination and power in the priesthood are two different things from what I understand. Ordination doesn't mean you have priesthood power but rather are admonished to be a high priest like unto Moses or Joseph. Faith and prayers alone can perform miracles. It isn't always a priesthood blessing that does the trick. It could be the silent mother's prays for her sick child for example. Hence many will say "Lord, Lord" but Christ will return and say I do not know you.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:46 am
by BenMcCrea
I don't think there will ever be a majority of Apostles, including the Senior Apostle, who will be in favor of same sex marriage.
Even if someone like Elder Christofferson, who's brother Tom is gay and married to his partner, was in favor of same sex marriage, you will always have a majority of men like Boyd K Packer, Russell M Nelson, Jeffrey R Holland, David A Bednar etc who will hold to the traditional view of marriage and tip the balance. I certainly hope so.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 11:50 am
by jwharton
I'd like to know if people have taken the time to read Romans 1:18-32.
Please read this from the point of view of what we have brought upon ourselves for rejecting the higher law of the fullness of the Gospel and Celestial Law.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:01 pm
by BenMcCrea
It is a very apparent fact that we have traveled far and wide in the past 20 years. What the future will bring I do not know. But if we drift as far afield from fundamental things in the next 20 years, what will be left of the foundation laid by the Prophet Joseph Smith? It is easy for one who observes to see how the apostasy came about in the primitive church of Christ. Are we not traveling the same road? (Joseph Fielding Smith Journal, 28 December 1938)
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:04 pm
by BenMcCrea
President Boyd K Packer:
In recent years I have felt, and I think I am not alone, that we are losing the ability to correct the course of the church. You cannot appreciate how deeply I feel about the importance of this present opportunity unless you know the regard, the reverence, I have for the Book of Mormon and how seriously I have taken the warnings of the prophets, particularly Alma and Helaman.
Both Alma and Helaman told the church in their day. They warned about fast growth, the desire to be accepted by the world, to be popular, and particularly they warned about prosperity. Each time those conditions existed in combination, the church has drifted off course. All of those conditions are present in the church today.
Helaman repeatedly warned, I think four times he used these words, that the fatal drift of the church could occur in the space of not many years. In one instance it took only six years. (Helaman 6:32; 7:6; 11:26) (“Let Them Govern Themselves,” Reg. Rep. Seminar, March 30, 1990, underline added)
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:07 pm
by jwharton
BenMcCrea wrote:It is a very apparent fact that we have traveled far and wide in the past 20 years. What the future will bring I do not know. But if we drift as far afield from fundamental things in the next 20 years, what will be left of the foundation laid by the Prophet Joseph Smith? It is easy for one who observes to see how the apostasy came about in the primitive church of Christ. Are we not traveling the same road? (Joseph Fielding Smith Journal, 28 December 1938)
:ymapplause:
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:10 pm
by BenMcCrea
President Spencer W Kimball:
…when I review the performance of this people in comparison with what is expected, I am appalled and frightened. If we insist on spending all our time and resources building up for ourselves a worldly kingdom, that is exactly what we will inherit. In spite of our delight in defining ourselves as modern, and our tendency to think we possess a sophistication that no people in the past ever had–in spite of these things, we are, on the whole, an idolatrous people–a condition most repugnant to the Lord. (Ensign, June, 1976)
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:15 pm
by jwharton
BenMcCrea wrote:President Spencer W Kimball:
…when I review the performance of this people in comparison with what is expected, I am appalled and frightened. If we insist on spending all our time and resources building up for ourselves a worldly kingdom, that is exactly what we will inherit. In spite of our delight in defining ourselves as modern, and our tendency to think we possess a sophistication that no people in the past ever had–in spite of these things, we are, on the whole, an idolatrous people–a condition most repugnant to the Lord. (Ensign, June, 1976)
:ymapplause:
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:17 pm
by BenMcCrea
President Ezra Taft Benson:
Certain individuals within the Church may go astray and even fall away. This may happen even to a person in the Church who is in a position of some influence and authority. It has happened in the past. It will happen in the future. If our faith is in Jesus Christ and not in the arm of flesh, then we will know that we are members of the Church of Jesus Christ and not the church of men. (Teachings of Ezra Taft Benson, Pg. 90)
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:26 pm
by Original_Intent
I'd just like to note that he didn't say it was "OK", he said that you would not lose your membership or your recommend for doing so.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:39 pm
by jwharton
Original_Intent wrote:I'd just like to note that he didn't say it was "OK", he said that you would not lose your membership or your recommend for doing so.
How can a person answer the questions faithfully to assert their worthiness to enter a temple if this is what they are supporting?
People are totally forgetting that under the law homosexuality is considered punishable at the same level of severity as adultery.
It is a sin that causes spiritual death and so the carnal law affixes the punishment of being stoned to death. It is extremely serious sin.
This is the equivalent of saying people who openly support people's right to have "open marriages" meaning consenting wife swapping, orgies, swinging, etc. are all things a person can openly promote and privately participate in with no worries about church discipline.
People have every right to be aghast at such a position being taken.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 12:49 pm
by Simon
jwharton wrote:Original_Intent wrote:I'd just like to note that he didn't say it was "OK", he said that you would not lose your membership or your recommend for doing so.
How can a person answer the questions faithfully to assert their worthiness to enter a temple if this is what they are supporting?
People are totally forgetting that under the law homosexuality is considered punishable at the same level of severity as adultery.
It is a sin that causes spiritual death and so the carnal law affixes the punishment of being stoned to death. It is extremely serious sin.
This is the equivalent of saying people who openly support people's right to have "open marriages" meaning consenting wife swapping, orgies, swinging, etc. are all things a person can openly promote and privately participate in with no worries about church discipline.
People have every right to be aghast at such a position being taken.
But lets not forget here that sin is only sin when people know it is such... We all have the right to believe and to support whatever we feel is right... I dont say this is what you ment to say, but we cant just go ahead and stone all the people that have such tendencys, or stone those who have loved ones in their family that feel that way, and that dont condemn them to death..
I do not believe that homosexuals experience more spiritual death thn those that would like to throw the first stone.
I feel when the church has its revelations about it, and people believe it, that is fine... But, it is their truth, and though we may openly share our views, and stand in for them, it is not neccesarely other peoples truth... guesss we need to learn to respect that.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 1:18 pm
by Tony
Jesus Christ's Church will never support iniquity. Hence, it will never support gay marriage, just like it will never support fornication.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 1:44 pm
by Lizzy60
Tony wrote:Jesus Christ's Church will never support iniquity. Hence, it will never support gay marriage, just like it will never support fornication.
But now they won't discipline you if you support the grievous sin of homosexuality, and the abomination that is gay marriage.
But they will discipline you if you don't support THEM (the Top 15 PSRs)
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 1:51 pm
by AGStacker
BenMcCrea wrote:I don't think there will ever be a majority of Apostles, including the Senior Apostle, who will be in favor of same sex marriage.
Even if someone like Elder Christofferson, who's brother Tom is gay and married to his partner, was in favor of same sex marriage, you will always have a majority of men like Boyd K Packer, Russell M Nelson, Jeffrey R Holland, David A Bednar etc who will hold to the traditional view of marriage and tip the balance. I certainly hope so.
Yes but these men slowly pass away and younger men take their places who are influenced by a more liberal people. In the 70s or 80s Packer, I think, openly said gays, intellectuals and feminists were a great threat. I am paraphrasing there. Could you imagine Elder Christofferson saying that today?!
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 1:54 pm
by caddis
Lizzy60 wrote:Tony wrote:Jesus Christ's Church will never support iniquity. Hence, it will never support gay marriage, just like it will never support fornication.
But now they won't discipline you if you support the grievous sin of homosexuality, and the abomination that is gay marriage.
But they will discipline you if you don't support THEM (the Top 15 PSRs)
Exactly! Support sin = okay. Don't support men = not okay.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 2:24 pm
by Obrien
samizdat wrote:briznian wrote:Muerte Rosa wrote:REALLY?
Yes. Really. You have not actually stated what you think his position is.
Elder Oaks has always been against gay marriage. If you are trying to suggest that the October 2014 Conference talk that he gave about civility is a tacit approval of gay marriage then you are surely mistaken.
Lizzy: that is going to happen, initially. Hopefully the Church takes the high road and doesn't accept gay marriage. The truth of the matter is that the Church is worldwide now and not just a Utah or even an American church.
Samizdat -that must take a lot for you to write a post like this.
It does not matter what Packer, Oaks, Ballard etc think about gay marriage. There is a clear age break in the Q 12 right now - Holland is the oldest "young' guy there is. Everyone above Holland is probably out of the picture in 5 years. There will be a sea change when Packer, Perry, Nelson, Oaks, Ballard, Scott and Hales (all of them over 82 and several over 90) pass the way of all the earth. There will likely be 7 new apostles in the near term, and that change will rock "policy" on the homosexual acceptance front. Hell, Christofferson will be one of the "senior" apostles then, and you've seen how pleased he is at the evolution of the thinking in the Q 12. God help us all.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 3:33 pm
by The ward heretic
This church of ours is a is quite a puzzle!
From brother Brigham till the 70s, we had the guts to face the world and say "blacks anit worthy of the PH, cuz dems guys gots a curse on dems skin, cuz Cain jacked up aBle... blah blah blah"
I mean really! we had the collective gal to really believe and justify that crap!!!!
**Now that there is something worth standing up for as a collective.....and we can't capitualate faster. **
Don't get me wrong. I think we can have tolerance and love for those with SSA. Jesus hang out with the low life sinners, and so can we. In fact, if christ were here now, he probably would be hanging out with and speaking to those very type of people; but he wouldn't justify their sins. Nor should we as a community of believers.
But we probably have/will.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 3:50 pm
by jwharton
Simon wrote:jwharton wrote:Original_Intent wrote:I'd just like to note that he didn't say it was "OK", he said that you would not lose your membership or your recommend for doing so.
How can a person answer the questions faithfully to assert their worthiness to enter a temple if this is what they are supporting?
People are totally forgetting that under the law homosexuality is considered punishable at the same level of severity as adultery.
It is a sin that causes spiritual death and so the carnal law affixes the punishment of being stoned to death. It is extremely serious sin.
This is the equivalent of saying people who openly support people's right to have "open marriages" meaning consenting wife swapping, orgies, swinging, etc. are all things a person can openly promote and privately participate in with no worries about church discipline.
People have every right to be aghast at such a position being taken.
But lets not forget here that sin is only sin when people know it is such... We all have the right to believe and to support whatever we feel is right... I dont say this is what you ment to say, but we cant just go ahead and stone all the people that have such tendencys, or stone those who have loved ones in their family that feel that way, and that dont condemn them to death..
I do not believe that homosexuals experience more spiritual death thn those that would like to throw the first stone.
I feel when the church has its revelations about it, and people believe it, that is fine... But, it is their truth, and though we may openly share our views, and stand in for them, it is not neccesarely other peoples truth... guesss we need to learn to respect that.
You make a good point where society in general is concerned.
However, when a person accepts the Gospel and makes a covenant to abide by its laws and principles, there needs to be fidelity to those laws.
There should be patience and understanding with those who struggle with same sex attraction.
But, there should be absolutely no acceptance of them identifying themselves as a homosexual.
If anyone who is a covenant member of the church identifies themselves as a homosexual, they should be warned to no longer uphold such an identity. And, if they refused and persist to identify themselves as such they should be excommunicated.
The parallel to this is if I am sexually attracted to my neighbor's wife, but do not act upon it, I should be treated with patience and understanding. However, if I cross the line to identify myself as someone intent upon pursuing sexual relations with my neighbor's wife, then I should be soundly rebuked and warned to cease and desist from having such intentions. If I persisted in my intent to have sexual relations then the appropriate action for the church is to hold me accountable to the level of what my intentions were. If I didn't repent of identifying myself as someone who should be able to have sex with my neighbor's wife, I should be excommunicated.
Anyone promoting acceptance of homosexuality who is a covenant member of the church should be treated exactly the same as if they were promoting the acceptance of wife swapping, swinging, orgies, etc. In God's eyes it is all a gross perversion of sacred powers that is cause for the Holy Ghost to immediately leave such people to their own devices. If the church does not take action to purge itself of such pollution, our status of condemnation will become all the worse in intensity.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 3:53 pm
by jwharton
Tony wrote:Jesus Christ's Church will never support iniquity.
Hence, it will never support gay marriage, just like it will never support fornication.
Just like the bride brought to Christ by those who caught her in the very act of adultery would never do such a thing?
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 3:53 pm
by samizdat
AGStacker wrote:BenMcCrea wrote:I don't think there will ever be a majority of Apostles, including the Senior Apostle, who will be in favor of same sex marriage.
Even if someone like Elder Christofferson, who's brother Tom is gay and married to his partner, was in favor of same sex marriage, you will always have a majority of men like Boyd K Packer, Russell M Nelson, Jeffrey R Holland, David A Bednar etc who will hold to the traditional view of marriage and tip the balance. I certainly hope so.
Yes but these men slowly pass away and younger men take their places who are influenced by a more liberal people. In the 70s or 80s Packer, I think, openly said gays, intellectuals and feminists were a great threat. I am paraphrasing there. Could you imagine Elder Christofferson saying that today?!
It was actually 92 or perhaps 93 when he said that. Today the leaders are MUCH more quiet especially after the flak that happened after Elder Packer made some more comments in 2010 and Elder Oaks just last year (or perhaps the year before) when he called gay marriage immoral.
Re: Apostle says it's okay to support gay marriage
Posted: March 19th, 2015, 4:26 pm
by Tony
Lizzy60 wrote:Tony wrote:Jesus Christ's Church will never support iniquity. Hence, it will never support gay marriage, just like it will never support fornication.
But now they won't discipline you if you support the grievous sin of homosexuality, and the abomination that is gay marriage.
But they will discipline you if you don't support THEM (the Top 15 PSRs)
Agency is essential to the eternal plan of salvation. People are entitled to feel anyway they want about gay marriage, but they will be disciplined if they advocate for gay marriage at Church. Someone will be denied a Temple recommend if they associate with a group that advocates for gay marriage.