Page 1 of 1
Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 5:00 pm
by Daryl
Just wondering what the actual doctrine is. Does the act of excommunication force the person being exed to somehow lose the Holy Ghost from their life. Obviously sin and other spiritual matter would result in loss of the spirit. My question is more about church leaders. Do church leaders claim to have the authority to remove the HG from someone who is exed? is this done by some priesthood ordinance?
I realize what the traditional belief is. I heard this doctrine being taught twice this year: once at a re-baptism & today in Sunday School.
From lds.org
EXCOMMUNICATION
See also Apostasy; Rebellion
The process of excluding a person from the Church and taking away all rights and privileges of membership. Church authorities excommunicate a person from the Church only when he has chosen to live in opposition to the Lord’s commandments and thus has disqualified himself for further membership in the Church.
Religious societies have the right to deal with members’ disorderly conduct:D&C 134:10;
10 We believe that all religious societies have a right to deal with their members for disorderly conduct, aaccording to the rules and regulations of such societies; provided that such dealings be for fellowship and good standing; but we do not believe that any religious society has bauthority to try men on the right of property or life, to take from them this world’s goods, or to put them in jeopardy of either life or limb, or to inflict any physical punishment upon them. They can only excommunicate them from their society, and withdraw from them their fellowship.
I have been looking around and so far I have not been able to find anything of a conclusive nature abut this traditional belief.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 5:39 pm
by lemuel
It's not clear to me that the Church confers the Holy Ghost. The ordinance is "I confirm you a member of the CoJCoLDS and say unto you 'Receive the Holy Ghost'". It doesn't ever give the Holy Ghost, it is just a charge for the individual to receive it.
Of course, doing most of the things that would get one ex'd would typically result in a loss of the influence of the HG.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 5:42 pm
by Bryan LJ
If we were to look at the life of Enos we probably could assume that he had been taught and perhaps baptized by his father Jacob whom had seen Christ. He had been baptized for the remission of sins already I assume. It is my understanding however that each ordinance has a spiritual side to each ordinance. As someone lays hands on our head they say, "Receive the Holy Ghost". If someone is wicked and they are faking their conversion to impress a parent or girlfriend or anyone else, do they receive the Holy Ghost still? Is this automatic? Therefore the spiritual side to the Laying on of hands for the HG would be actually receiving the HG in my opinion.
With baptism I believe the spiritual side to that ordinance is receiving the Baptism of Fire or in other words the remission or forgiveness of sins. Enos received that baptism when he sought God personally not necessarily by the act of getting baptized. Same with works of darkness. If Enos would have later committed adultery, shed innocent blood or would have done anything seriously to offend God after having received his spirit would not he have lost the spirit in or before that act? Then later if he would have got booted out of the church they would be just acknowledging that God had already cut him off.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 5:48 pm
by Bryan LJ
Time to push the envelope! (See Words of JS) Joseph Smith taught that there are 3 priesthoods and that the church only has 2 of them. He taught that Abraham received the 2nd from Melchizedek and later received the 3rd one from God after Abraham had been tested with sacrificing his son Isaac. The question is could the church take the 3rd priesthood away from someone like Abraham whom did not receive it from them? I believe the same applies to your scenario.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 5:49 pm
by marc
Jesus Christ is very clear that HE is the One who baptizes with fire and the Holy Ghost. That said, if a person commits a sin grievous enough to be excommunicated, then what is sealed on earth is sealed in heaven also. Their name is blotted out. We read this in the Book of Mormon. Just my thoughts anyway.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 6:37 pm
by Daryl
OK, so i went digging around and I found some information in the church handbook of instruction:
Pg21 Effects of Excommunication or Name Removal
After a husband and wife have been sealed in a temple, if one of them is excommunicated or has his or her name removed from Church membership records, his Ol' her temple blessings are revoked. However, the sealing blessings of the innocent spouse and of children born in the covenant are not affected.
Pg 22 Persons Who Were Excommunicated or Had Their Names Removed from Church Records
First Presidency approval is required to per- form temple ordinances for deceased persons who, at the time of their death, were excommu- nicated or had their names removed from Church membership records. A Letter should be written to the Office of the First Presidency. No form1 is required.
Restoration of Temple Blessings (after Excommunication or Name Removal) Endowed persons who were excommunicated (or who had their names removed from Church membership records) and were later readmitted by baptism and confirmation can receive their priesthood and temple blessings only through the ordinance of restoration of blessings. Such per- sons are not ordained to any priesthood office or endowed again, since these blessings are re- stored through the ordinance. For information about perfom1ing this ordinance for the living, see 6.15. First Presidency approval is required to per- form this ordinance for the dead.
Pg59 6.9.3 Excommunication
A person who is excommunicated is no Jon· ger a member of the Church. Excommunication is the most severe Church disciplinary action. As directed by the Spirit, it may be necessary for: 1. Members who have committed serious trans· gressions, especially violations of temple covenants (see "Violation of Covenants" in 6.10.6). 2. Members who have been disfellowshipped and have not repented and for whom ex- communication seems to offer the best hope for reformation. 3. Members whose conduct makes them a seri- ous threat to others and whose Church mem- bership facilitates their a~s to victims. 4. Church leaders or prominent members whose transgressions significantly impair the good name or moral influence of lhe Church in the community that is aware of the transgres· sion. Excommunication is mandatory for murder (as defined in 6.7.3) and is almost always required for incest. A person who is excommunicated does not enjoy any privileges of Church membership. He may not wear temple garments or pay tithes and offerings. He may attend public Church meet- ings if his conduct is orderly, but his participa- tion in such meetings is limited the same as for disfellowshipped members. Excommunication almost always lasts at least one year. If a person shows true repentance and satisfies the conditions imposed while he is ex- communicated, he may be readmitted by bap- tism and confirmation. The read mission process is explained in 6.12. For information about the effects of excom- munication on temple sealings, see "Effects of Excommunication or Name Removal" in 3.6.1.
Pg 73 Restoration of Blessings
Endowed persons who were excommuni- cated and . latex readmitted by baptism and con· firmation can receive their priesthood a.nd temple blessings only through the ordinance of restora- tion of blessings. Such persons are not ordained to priesthood offices or endowed again, since all priesU1ood and temple blessings held at the time of excommurucation are restored through the ordinance. Brethren are restored to their for· mer priesthood office, except the office of sev- enty, bishop, or patriarch. (See also 6.12.12.) Only the First Presidency can approve the performance of the ordinance of restoration of blessings. The First Presidency will not consider an application for this ordina . nce sooner than one year after the person is readmitted by baptism and confirmation. To submit a recommendation to the First Presidency, the presiding officer completes each step on the Application to the First Presidency form. This form is available electronically in units that use Church record-keeping software. In other areas it is available from the Area Presi· dency.
Note: this is from a scanned copy, so not all the words are correct.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 6:50 pm
by Original_Intent
I know you are looking for doctrine, I do not know of any other than the church handbook.
That being said, I cannot imagine that Helmuth Hubener went to his execution without the companionship of the Holy Ghost, and I suspect others.
Your question seems to be does the act of excommunication (or any other action that man can take) direct the powers of heaven. I believe not, but obviously spoken as opinion and with no authority.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 8:34 pm
by boo
Consider Avraham Gileadi who was excommunicated as one of the Sept 6 but was subsequently brought back into full fellowship and reinstated not by being rebaptized and receiving a restoration of blessings through the ordinance of the same name but simply by having his excommunication expunged , i.e. as if it never happened. He wasn't required to be reconfirmed .I am certain he had the Holy Ghost before he was excommunicated and does now. He is presently is full fellowship. This bizarre sequence suggests to me that losing the Holy Ghost doesn't necessarily happen as a result of an administrative decision but in the same way that obtaining the gift of the Holy Ghost in the first place is between the member and God ,losing it is between the member and God ;not a group of bureaucrats . I have two brothers ,both of whom were excommunicated and both of whom were rebaptized. They will both tell you they enjoyed the companionship of the Holy Ghost at times while they were excommunicated.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 8:52 pm
by Daryl
So it sounds like just a false idea some people perpetuate. One of those gospel myths. Is that correct?
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 8:53 pm
by boo
In my view yes
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 9:05 pm
by freedomforall
Read "The Worth of a Soul" by Steven A. Cramer. He was ex'd and describes what he went through, and his recovery. He does say, however, "when a person is excommunicated as a result of violating sacred temple covenants, he is not only expelled from the membership of Christ's church, he is also delivered over to the 'buffetings of Satan.'"
He knows, he went through it.
I myself have experienced the buffetings of Satan, and I was not an ex'd member. Just someone that went down the wrong path until I hit bottom, and asked Christ for deliverance. It took many, many months of changes, reading good books, prayer and feasting on the word. Then the day came that peace, comfort, joy and happiness came into my being. The buffetings of Satan ARE REAL, believe it.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 9:26 pm
by Bee Prepared
When a person is excommunicated, it is not an end to all blessings and eternal possibilities. We members are obligated to forgive
that member, not worry about whether or not the person has lost the " Holy Ghost".
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 9:41 pm
by FoxMammaWisdom
Daryl, you are taunting me with this post. ;)
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 10:14 pm
by Daryl
freedomfighter wrote:Read "The Worth of a Soul" by Steven A. Cramer. He was ex'd and describes what he went through, and his recovery. He does say, however, "when a person is excommunicated as a result of violating sacred temple covenants, he is not only expelled from the membership of Christ's church, he is also delivered over to the 'buffetings of Satan.'"
He knows, he went through it.
I myself have experienced the buffetings of Satan, and I was not an ex'd member. Just someone that went down the wrong path until I hit bottom, and asked Christ for deliverance. It took many, many months of changes, reading good books, prayer and feasting on the word. Then the day came that peace, comfort, joy and happiness came into my being. The buffetings of Satan ARE REAL, believe it.
Thanks for sharing that. I have read Cramer's book. Good call. It was when I was going through my own hard time. I agree, for most people at least initially, the sins that get them exed crush the spirit in their lives. But for people who make horrible mistakes that leave them outside the church for years, I think it very uncharitable to assume they don't have the Spirit in there lives. It's especially unkind to teach or tell them that. Kinda like telling a convert before they are baptized that they can't have the HG minister to them until they are baptized. Know what I mean?
So if this idea that people automatically lose the HG because they get exed is a false tradition, we should probably be aware of that.
everything I can find on it from the church does not include this idea. We should refer people back to the truth published by the church, if its appropriate for us to do so.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 10:15 pm
by Daryl
Bee Prepared wrote:When a person is excommunicated, it is not an end to all blessings and eternal possibilities. We members are obligated to forgive
that member, not worry about whether or not the person has lost the " Holy Ghost".
amen!!!
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 10:17 pm
by Daryl
Jules wrote:Daryl, you are taunting me with this post. ;)
Take the bait, friend. j/k.
I'm not trying to bash anyone or anything. Just trying to get to the heart of truth.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 17th, 2013, 10:27 pm
by freedomforall
Daryl wrote:freedomfighter wrote:Read "The Worth of a Soul" by Steven A. Cramer. He was ex'd and describes what he went through, and his recovery. He does say, however, "when a person is excommunicated as a result of violating sacred temple covenants, he is not only expelled from the membership of Christ's church, he is also delivered over to the 'buffetings of Satan.'"
He knows, he went through it.
I myself have experienced the buffetings of Satan, and I was not an ex'd member. Just someone that went down the wrong path until I hit bottom, and asked Christ for deliverance. It took many, many months of changes, reading good books, prayer and feasting on the word. Then the day came that peace, comfort, joy and happiness came into my being. The buffetings of Satan ARE REAL, believe it.
Thanks for sharing that. I have read Cramer's book. Good call. It was when I was going through my own hard time. I agree, for most people at least initially, the sins that get them exed crush the spirit in their lives. But for people who make horrible mistakes that leave them outside the church for years, I think it very uncharitable to assume they don't have the Spirit in there lives. It's especially unkind to teach or tell them that. Kinda like telling a convert before they are baptized that they can't have the HG minister to them until they are baptized. Know what I mean?
So if this idea that people automatically lose the HG because they get exed is a false tradition, we should probably be aware of that.
everything I can find on it from the church does not include this idea. We should refer people back to the truth published by the church, if its appropriate for us to do so.
What we humans keep forgetting is that God will do as He wills. It is not up to us to say anyone cannot experience the HG. God doesn't care how bad a person sinned, only that they come to him with a broken heart and a contrite spirit, and to repent having real intent and purpose. This is when the Atonement can take full effect. This I know from experience.
Even those who have been ex'd, they have a way back if they want it.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 18th, 2013, 8:34 am
by sleepyhead
Hello Daryl,
The following is in regard to the comments about the restoration of blessings. In Genesis Jacob and Esau were brothers. Esau was the elder and therefore the one entitled to Isaac's blessing. Through subterfuge Jacob was able to convince Isaac to give him the blessing. When Esau came for his blessing he pleaded with Isaac to bless him but there was nothing Isaac could do. He had given Jacob the blessing and he couldn't take it away from him. Therefore the church can't restore any blessings that were previously given because you don't lose them. Any blessings you were given are yours regardless of your status in the church.
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 18th, 2013, 8:58 am
by Simon
I would asume you could similarely ask wether only members in church who are baptized have the gift of the Holy Ghost, or wether God has bestowed that gift also upon others outside the church.
I think it also depends upon wether the excommunication is truely God's command or manmade. Never say never ;)
Re: Does one lose the Holy Ghost when excommunicated
Posted: November 18th, 2013, 9:32 am
by TheLion
I'd say it depends why someone is excommunicated. Their actions may indeed lead to losing the Holy Ghost. Having said that, no Church on Earth has the power over God to dictate who he blesses.