SB744
Posted: August 10th, 2013, 9:09 am
In a visit yesterday to the local office of Arizona Congressional Representative Matt Salmon I learned that certain of his staff have read and studied the "Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act of 2013" (S.744) and recently compiled a list of the "Top 15 Reasons why SB 744 is a bad idea". Following is their list:
Top 15 Reasons Why SB 744 is a bad idea
1. Does not require any additional border fencing or the completion of our current border fencing requirements. Only requires DHS to submit to Congress a strategy of recommendations for additional necessary fencing.
2. Authorizes DHS to waive unlawful behavior when determining admissibility of undocumented immigrants, including: gang membership, three or more DUIs, domestic violence, child abuse, crimes of moral turpitude, drug law violations, passport trafficking, providing fraudulent immigration services, prostitution, visa violations, and all other violations not specifically listed in the bill.
3. Allows DHS to grant legal status in 6 months, prior to any measures to secure the border.
4. Voids state and local E-verify laws.
5. Prohibits immigration enforcement actions in ‘sensitive areas’ including: hospitals, schools, churches, and certain organizations.
6. Does not provide for punishment of undocumented immigrants who make false statements in a registered provisional immigrant application. Yet it creates criminal penalties and a fine up to $10,000 for federal official who discloses information found on an application.
7. Does not require the deportation of a single undocumented immigrant. DHS is not explicitly required to deport an immigrant whose RPI application is denied.
8. Allows Secretary of DHS to exercise discretion to waive a ground of inadmissibility or deportability if the Secretary deems it to be against the public interest or a hardship to the family of the deportable individual.
9. Allows undocumented immigrants to bring class action lawsuits against the government for denial of RPI status.
10. Requires DHS to waive the public charge law when determining which immigrants are eligible for legal status.
11. Requires that passport forgers would no longer be prosecuted for making a single fake travel document, with the bar being set at three.
12. Requires that document counterfeiters whose materials are used to obtain passports would only be jailed if they contributed to at least 10 phony passports. This bill creates a new non-profit organization (501 c3) which will be administered by the above referenced community organizations and paid for by the tax payer.
13. The 10 years of employment requirement will be waived if: The illegal is a student or has been one, is or cared for an elderly person or persons, have been involved in community service or if, in his or her opinion, is unemployed through no fault of his or her own.
14. Describes functions and implementations of this bill to be an "emergency" and any government "emergency" can be funded without stipulation to cost or where the money will come from.
15. This bill will put border security and border agents under the control of the Office of Civil Rights of the Department of Justice. There is funding for sensitivity training of our agents to ensure they don't ask hard questions of border jumpers. Just one example, the bill suggests agents be ordered not ask for documentation.
The copy of the bill I scanned in the representative's office in Gilbert, AZ filled three 3-ring binders and was double spaced.
Top 15 Reasons Why SB 744 is a bad idea
1. Does not require any additional border fencing or the completion of our current border fencing requirements. Only requires DHS to submit to Congress a strategy of recommendations for additional necessary fencing.
2. Authorizes DHS to waive unlawful behavior when determining admissibility of undocumented immigrants, including: gang membership, three or more DUIs, domestic violence, child abuse, crimes of moral turpitude, drug law violations, passport trafficking, providing fraudulent immigration services, prostitution, visa violations, and all other violations not specifically listed in the bill.
3. Allows DHS to grant legal status in 6 months, prior to any measures to secure the border.
4. Voids state and local E-verify laws.
5. Prohibits immigration enforcement actions in ‘sensitive areas’ including: hospitals, schools, churches, and certain organizations.
6. Does not provide for punishment of undocumented immigrants who make false statements in a registered provisional immigrant application. Yet it creates criminal penalties and a fine up to $10,000 for federal official who discloses information found on an application.
7. Does not require the deportation of a single undocumented immigrant. DHS is not explicitly required to deport an immigrant whose RPI application is denied.
8. Allows Secretary of DHS to exercise discretion to waive a ground of inadmissibility or deportability if the Secretary deems it to be against the public interest or a hardship to the family of the deportable individual.
9. Allows undocumented immigrants to bring class action lawsuits against the government for denial of RPI status.
10. Requires DHS to waive the public charge law when determining which immigrants are eligible for legal status.
11. Requires that passport forgers would no longer be prosecuted for making a single fake travel document, with the bar being set at three.
12. Requires that document counterfeiters whose materials are used to obtain passports would only be jailed if they contributed to at least 10 phony passports. This bill creates a new non-profit organization (501 c3) which will be administered by the above referenced community organizations and paid for by the tax payer.
13. The 10 years of employment requirement will be waived if: The illegal is a student or has been one, is or cared for an elderly person or persons, have been involved in community service or if, in his or her opinion, is unemployed through no fault of his or her own.
14. Describes functions and implementations of this bill to be an "emergency" and any government "emergency" can be funded without stipulation to cost or where the money will come from.
15. This bill will put border security and border agents under the control of the Office of Civil Rights of the Department of Justice. There is funding for sensitivity training of our agents to ensure they don't ask hard questions of border jumpers. Just one example, the bill suggests agents be ordered not ask for documentation.
The copy of the bill I scanned in the representative's office in Gilbert, AZ filled three 3-ring binders and was double spaced.