Daryl wrote:Just a follow-up thought...
Would Jesus say to someone, "Do you have the faith not to be healed"? Maybe there is a scripture where Christ did exactly that. I just don't recall any canonized stories of the Lord's anointed propositioning an ill requester in such a way. I'm sure someone with more knowledge in the scriptures would have a reference for us.
I do remember a story where Joseph Smith couldn't physically attend to an ill partitioner so he blessed a hanky and handed it to a priesthood brother and said to deliver it to the ill person and they would be made whole. Many people have ridiculed Joseph for dabbling in metaphysical/witchcraf arts. Until Joseph opened the scriptures and showed where Christ had done the same.
My guess is Christ answers requests for healing with yea, yea or neah, neah. Again I am no scriptorian. Just trying to get my head around Elder Bednar's doctrine.
It's certainly a worthwhile question. It might be worth adding some additional context to the words the Elder Bednar shared. He didn't just simply state "Do you have the faith not to be healed?". There was more than that. He said an
inspired question came to him and it was "If it is the will of our Heavenly Father, do you have the faith to not be healed?" He made sure that they understood that the blessing of healing could only be received if they had the faith not to be healed and were "willing to submit to all things which the Lord seeth fit to inflict upon [them]” (Mosiah 3:19). In other words, do you trust in God sufficiently that your belief in His goodness isn't dependent on this miracle. If your trust is truly that deep, then perhaps you have what it takes to truly seek this miracle. They came to understand that "not shrinking is more important than surviving. Thus, their experience was not primarily about living and dying; rather, it was about learning, living, and becoming." Sounds remarkably reminiscent of the words God shared with Joseph, "thine adversity and afflictions shall be but a small moment, and then if thou endure it well, God shall exalt thee on high." Or "know thou my son that all these things shall give thee experience, and shall be for thy good. The Son of Man have descended below them all. Art thou greater than he?"
This wasn't about Elder Bednar downplaying the gift of healing, it was about teaching them of the kind of faith necessary to obtain healing. It has to be a faith so deep that total submission to His will is first and foremost.
Scipturally speaking, I could ask you - was it just that Christ didn't have enough faith to be delivered of his burdens when he said "Abba, Father, all things are possible unto thee, take this cup from me: nevertheless not what I will, but what thou wilt." He made a declaration of faith that all things were possible to God, but that he'd submit to God's will. Maybe he should have just asked more faithfully and that part could have been skipped.
Or what about Joseph in Liberty Jail. Did he just not have enough faith to shatter the prison walls like Alma and Amulek did? They were only in there for 3 days, but Joseph was in Liberty for 5 months, and got quite sick while there.
Or what about that same Alma and Amulek...the ones with faith sufficient to have the walls of a prison crumble around them...did they not have faith sufficient just a few verses before to save those being cast into a burning fire? No, it was that the will of God took precedence.
Perhaps it was that the people on the front lines who fell among the Anti-Nehpi-Lehi's are the ones who didn't have faith, but the ones in the back did, and that's why they were spared and others weren't. Or, was it that the faith of ALL OF THEM transcended the need to have a specific result. They were more committed to doing rightly and submitting fully to God. I find it fascinating that they had the faith to both kneel down in front of their attackers....and those who survived then the faith to continue on trusting God after losing senselessly so many friends and family. They could have said to themselves in anger "He saved half of us, why not just save everybody? Does he just not care?" But no...their trust in God was complete, no murmuring followed the great loss that would accompany them the rest of their lives. Their faith put their own lives in God's hands, and then they faithfully endured deep loss forever after.
I see no absence of scriptural evidence for the principles being taught in this talk. Perhaps the very words "Do you have the faith not to be healed" are not scriptural. But those words don't make up the whole of his message to that couple. His message was much deeper than that, and it would be unfair to only analyze that single statement outside of the full context. The question he asked was a teaching moment to suggest that real faith in God always involves humbly submitting to His will.
I don't want to make this about Denver, because it isn't. I happen to enjoy Denver's teaching style and message, and I know Daryl does as well. So I'll end with one more analogy that I think will put Elder Bednar's comment into proper context. Taking only the question "Do you have the faith not to be healed" outside of the context of his entire discussion with the couple and outside of the context of the entire talk (which dealt not just with healing, but adversity of all kinds), would be like only looking at one of the 20 questions Denver lists on a single post and questioning the doctrinal nature of that question in isolation while ignoring that the question was designed to be a teaching moment in the context of the entire post and all 20 questions. In fact, the question may be anything but doctrinal, but he's specifically asking you the question to get you to dig deeper and discover truth.
Asking questions, even uncomfortable ones, is often a great way to teach. In this case, Elder Bednar used the question we are discussing to help them discover how deep their faith really went. I think it was quite effective. We need not assume that means they were then passive about that faith and let death approach. Instead it may have helped them more fully submit and more faithfully petition.
Alma 24:27 "Thus we see that the Lord worketh in many ways to the salvation of his people." He works in both death and life, he works in both prosperity and adversity. He is not just the God of the healed, he is the God of those sick and dying as well; and their suffering, if they endure it well, works to their salvation just as much as the one who had faith to be healed.
It truly is "less about living and dying; more about learning and becoming" one who can faithfully "submit to all things which the Lord seeth fit to inflict upon them".
Respectfully,
Danny