Re: The Fastest Way to Make Your Calling and Election Sure
Posted: June 18th, 2014, 8:29 pm
Pontius explains the difference between the HG and Holy Spirt quite well in Following T Light into His Presence.
Njb
Njb
Your home for discussing politics, the restored gospel of Jesus Christ, and the principles of liberty.
https://ldsfreedomforum.com/
Very good point. An excellent volume.notjamesbond003.5 wrote:Pontius explains the difference between the HG and Holy Spirt quite well in Following T Light into His Presence.
Njb
Jeremy knows EXACTLY what he's talking about - he just likes to make people think ;) .boo wrote:Jeremy I am confident that you already know and know more fully than I. Nonetheless I take the bait and say that I believe it is clear that the Holy Ghost and the holy spirit are not the same .Unfortunately the scriptures ,while inspired, are ultimately the words of fallible men and usually lack a careful definitional section such as you might find in a well crafted legal agreement. Hence ambiguities occur. The Holy Ghost dwells within us as a personage of spirit and our bodies are its temple. 1 Corth 6:19. As our deepest spiritual component it will have to pass through probations with us until we are ultimately exalted. Hence Joseph's statement that that the" Holy Ghost would have to pass through a similar course of things as the Son has" and as we will If we don't we can not inherit the things the Father has for us. Lectures on Faith 6 v 8.It is as we learn to follow its voice that we will reach our potential as sons of god. The Holy Spirit is the mind of God and the Godhead ( the father and son) Lectures on Faith #5. It can range throughout time and space since it is not confined to a body or spirit.Think of the Light of Christ D&C 88:7 Incidentally while I quite liked Marion G Romney and admired his willingness to talk about thing like C/E in general conference he was not infallible and think he made some errors in this talk.Jeremy wrote:I'm still missing it. Someone help?! Please. Am I the only one who sees a paradox here?
Thanks for trying FFA. But I just do NOT see how that helps... other than I just take his word for it. But I want to KNOW. I want to understand.
Again, this is an example of your reading something, making assumptions based on traditions, and say the scripture says something that it doesn't say.Ask yourself these questions. Just how many is "us"? And where does "us" reside? If two people on opposite sides of the earth receive the gift of the Holy Ghost at the same time, does only one get it and the other has to wait? Verse 22 kind of answers these things for us does it not? As a personage of spirit it can dwell in multiple persons at the same time.
At this point I am willing to bow out of this conversation. I have given my view, backed by scripture and talks. The responsibility of knowing who the Holy Ghost is does not rest on me any longer, fore I already know. The people here who reject my words and documented proof have their own beliefs and I'm fine with that. I will not bend truth to blend in, rather, I will stick with what I know to be true because of my studies and prayers...and that is all that matters. What everyone else believes does not effect my salvation in the least. Precepts of men are just that, precepts of men. Questions I pose get ignored. Scriptures I cite get torn apart, thus, we are going nowhere. The lectures on faith were known not to give a full account of the members of the Godhead, whereas, scriptures (that I have already posted) teach us that the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost are one God. That's good enough for me. For those that reject this, what more can I say. If I believe these scriptures and they do not, who is responsible for the rejection?Jules wrote:Jeremy knows EXACTLY what he's talking about - he just likes to make people think ;) .boo wrote:Jeremy I am confident that you already know and know more fully than I. Nonetheless I take the bait and say that I believe it is clear that the Holy Ghost and the holy spirit are not the same .Unfortunately the scriptures ,while inspired, are ultimately the words of fallible men and usually lack a careful definitional section such as you might find in a well crafted legal agreement. Hence ambiguities occur. The Holy Ghost dwells within us as a personage of spirit and our bodies are its temple. 1 Corth 6:19. As our deepest spiritual component it will have to pass through probations with us until we are ultimately exalted. Hence Joseph's statement that that the" Holy Ghost would have to pass through a similar course of things as the Son has" and as we will If we don't we can not inherit the things the Father has for us. Lectures on Faith 6 v 8.It is as we learn to follow its voice that we will reach our potential as sons of god. The Holy Spirit is the mind of God and the Godhead ( the father and son) Lectures on Faith #5. It can range throughout time and space since it is not confined to a body or spirit.Think of the Light of Christ D&C 88:7 Incidentally while I quite liked Marion G Romney and admired his willingness to talk about thing like C/E in general conference he was not infallible and think he made some errors in this talk.Jeremy wrote:I'm still missing it. Someone help?! Please. Am I the only one who sees a paradox here?
Thanks for trying FFA. But I just do NOT see how that helps... other than I just take his word for it. But I want to KNOW. I want to understand.
FF - WHO is the Holy Ghost? THAT is important to understand. That's what all this is leading up to.
And I know this philosophy is in error, so where do you go from here? Do you think that the HG is just some guy who sits on his hind end and hangs out a shingle that says "come unto me and I'll teach you some things about yourself, and if you really press me, I may throw in some things about God?"Original_Intent wrote:Again, this is an example of your reading something, making assumptions based on traditions, and say the scripture says something that it doesn't say.Ask yourself these questions. Just how many is "us"? And where does "us" reside? If two people on opposite sides of the earth receive the gift of the Holy Ghost at the same time, does only one get it and the other has to wait? Verse 22 kind of answers these things for us does it not? As a personage of spirit it can dwell in multiple persons at the same time.
Even you say "if two people receive the gift of the Holy Ghost....etc" and I am saying to you again the Gift of the Holy Ghost is NOT THE SAME THING as the Holy Ghost.
You say verse 22 kind of answers those things. I agree with every single thing in verse 22, so either one of us is missing something, or one of us is adding to what is actually said, we are adding what we think we read because we think we already have the answer. I know which of us you feel is mistaken, and if "getting the win" is what matters to you, fine, you win. I told you what Marion Romney said and he didn't mince words.
The Holy Ghost can and does dwell in our hearts. And minds.
The Holy Ghost is a personage (personage means in the image of a person, btw) of spirit. So please get the Catholic idea of any member of the Godhead being some kind of universe sized nebulous blob out of your head. Based on what personage means, the only way the HG fills the universe is if the universe itself in the form of a person (not impossible).
You also seem to think the HG is some kind of being that can process experience of billions of beings simultaneously - an infinite multitasker - now if anything I am saying is making you uncomfortable, I suggest taking it up with the Lord, he loves questions (and questioners!) Of course you can just retreat into God's ways are not man's ways, this is something we simply can't comprehend - I tell you that it is comprehensible, but a full cup can't be filled any more....
freedomforall wrote:The lectures on faith were known not to give a full account of the members of the Godhead, whereas, scriptures (that I have already posted) teach us that the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost are one God.
The lectures might not give a full account, but apparently they lay a sure foundation. When something contradicts this sure foundation I have to start asking questions. I lack wisdom. I lack knowledge.Does the foregoing account of the Godhead lay a sure foundation for the exercise of faith in him unto life and salvation?" - "It does." Questions and Answers from page 58 of 1835 D&C
Accepting the scriptures I showed where the Father, Son and Holy Ghost are one...will give a sure foundation as well. They provide knowledge and can make people wise.Jeremy wrote:freedomforall wrote:The lectures on faith were known not to give a full account of the members of the Godhead, whereas, scriptures (that I have already posted) teach us that the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost are one God.The lectures might not give a full account, but apparently they lay a sure foundation. When something contradicts this sure foundation I have to start asking questions. I lack wisdom. I lack knowledge.Does the foregoing account of the Godhead lay a sure foundation for the exercise of faith in him unto life and salvation?" - "It does." Questions and Answers from page 58 of 1835 D&C
As for knowing what I'm talking about...Jules is incorrect. I would like to help us think more though.
The Spirit of God which emanates from Deity may be likened to electricity, ...which fills the earth and the air, and is everywhere present. It is the power of God, the influence that he exerts throughout all his works, by which he can effect his purposes and execute his will, in consonance with the laws of free agency which he has conferred upon man. (Gospel Doctrine, p 61-62, see also Mormon Doctrine "Spirit of the Lord")
I'm out of time but there are more such quotes. However, as I said, they are of little worth if a person does not tune themselves to hear the truth by the power of the Holy Ghost.The Savior while on earth declared that "It is the spirit that quickeneth" (John 6:63); and in modern times, speaking to Joseph Smith the Prophet, He said, "the Spirit beareth record" (D. & C. 1:39; 59:24); and "the Spirit giveth light to every man." (D. & C. 84:46) The Apostle Paul, interpreting life in terms of this doctrine, wrote "the things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God." (I Corinthians 2:11) This profound yet almost self-evident truth is the beginning of an understanding of the gospel.
The radio now found in almost every household illustrates the meaning of this doctrine. Broadcast throughout space are countless messages, music or the spoken word—some good, others bad. We are immersed in these radio waves or radiations or whatever they may be; they beat upon our senses as waves upon the ocean shore. Yet, we are not conscious of them unless our receiving set is tuned to catch them. Then they are converted into sound waves that activate our eardrums. That which eluded our senses, suddenly enters our world of hearing. ...It is so in the pursuit of spiritual truth. There, the seeker deals with living, personal realities; not primarily with the inert, impersonal things and forces of science. The Holy Spirit, which is in touch with every person born into the world, is the communicating agent. In this field, man, a living being, must be the chief instrument of reception as well as the interpreter of the knowledge offered by the Spirit of God. Therefore, the individual must be properly prepared, tuned, if he is to receive and to comprehend spiritual truth. In short, to understand "things of God," a person, who is the receiving apparatus, must qualify himself spiritually.(Widstoe, Evidences and Reconciliations, "11. Why Cannot the Things of God be Known But by the Spirit of God" http://www.cumorah.com/language/evidenc ... tions.html)
freedomforall wrote:And I know this philosophy is in error, so where do you go from here? Do you think that the HG is just some guy who sits on his hind end and hangs out a shingle that says "come unto me and I'll teach you some things about yourself, and if you really press me, I may throw in some things about God?"Original_Intent wrote:Again, this is an example of your reading something, making assumptions based on traditions, and say the scripture says something that it doesn't say.Ask yourself these questions. Just how many is "us"? And where does "us" reside? If two people on opposite sides of the earth receive the gift of the Holy Ghost at the same time, does only one get it and the other has to wait? Verse 22 kind of answers these things for us does it not? As a personage of spirit it can dwell in multiple persons at the same time.
Even you say "if two people receive the gift of the Holy Ghost....etc" and I am saying to you again the Gift of the Holy Ghost is NOT THE SAME THING as the Holy Ghost.
You say verse 22 kind of answers those things. I agree with every single thing in verse 22, so either one of us is missing something, or one of us is adding to what is actually said, we are adding what we think we read because we think we already have the answer. I know which of us you feel is mistaken, and if "getting the win" is what matters to you, fine, you win. I told you what Marion Romney said and he didn't mince words.
The Holy Ghost can and does dwell in our hearts. And minds.
The Holy Ghost is a personage (personage means in the image of a person, btw) of spirit. So please get the Catholic idea of any member of the Godhead being some kind of universe sized nebulous blob out of your head. Based on what personage means, the only way the HG fills the universe is if the universe itself in the form of a person (not impossible).
You also seem to think the HG is some kind of being that can process experience of billions of beings simultaneously - an infinite multitasker - now if anything I am saying is making you uncomfortable, I suggest taking it up with the Lord, he loves questions (and questioners!) Of course you can just retreat into God's ways are not man's ways, this is something we simply can't comprehend - I tell you that it is comprehensible, but a full cup can't be filled any more....
BTW, when Christ appeared to the brother of Jared, he appeared as a personage of spirit.
16 Behold, this body, which ye now behold, is the body of my spirit; and man have I created after the body of my spirit; and even as I appear unto thee to be in the spirit will I appear unto my people in the flesh.
The Holy Ghost has the power and authority to influence any person at any time as witness to Jesus and the Father, it is his role. Even in the Book of Mormon many people were converted to the gospel at the very same moment...and it was the Holy Ghost doing it. I rest my case OI. Sorry to burst your bubble. You know what opinions are equated to. What I teach comes out of scripture, and is not an opinion.
Just reads the larger font and discover that I know what I'm talking about. The Holy Ghost has the power to be everywhere. Let's pose the question like this:rproe67 wrote:This is WAY TOO LONG and has been made complicated beyond belief! :ymsick: Then buy a slow watch, you can get more done that way. As for being too long, take it up with Marion G Romney. I am not the author of the message, only the messenger of it. Besides, take note of how many long posts are posted. One would think books are in the works. :ymsigh:
If I try to prove something using everyone else's words even a former "prophet", how can that be convincing?! I'm patiently learning that if I want to know truth, it has to come directly from God...to "my" spirit! O:-)
Personally, I visualize the Holy Ghost as a network, like the Internet. But, instead of computers or nodes being all linked together to form a network or an internet, with the Holy Ghost, you have lots of different spirit beings all linked together telepathically to a central server, the God that we call the Holy Ghost.freedomforall wrote:
Just reads the larger font and discover that I know what I'm talking about. The Holy Ghost has the power to be everywhere. Let's pose the question like this:
If the personage of Spirit known as the HG cannot be everywhere at the same time, then how is it that people all over the globe can feel his influence or get guidance from him, all simultaneously?
I have also visualized something along this theme. I have surmised that the spirit body or spirit brain is some kind of infinite and unlimited recorder or memory storage device, like a hard drive. There are some files, folders, or memories that have been locked and require a password to get into.boo wrote:FFA That is easy and has been explained before .Let him who has ears hear. Each of us is our own Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost is the divine, eternal ,personage of spirit or " record of heaven" which dwells within us and whose whisperings we must learn to discern if we are to find our way back to the Father. Paul was not just speaking metaphorically when he said "know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost WHO IS IN YOU"" I Corth 6:19. I have pointed this out previously on this very thread. You can of course continue to ignore this truth or you can pray about it with an open and believing mind and perhaps your own "record of heaven" may whisper the truth of it to you. Try the experiment and good luck
Yes and this post I am responding to is a great lesson in humility.boo wrote:FFA That is easy and has been explained before .Let him who has ears hear. Each of us is our own Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost is the divine, eternal ,personage of spirit or " record of heaven" which dwells within us and whose whisperings we must learn to discern if we are to find our way back to the Father. Paul was not just speaking metaphorically when he said "know ye not that your body is the temple of the Holy Ghost WHO IS IN YOU"" I Corth 6:19. I have pointed this out previously on this very thread. You can of course continue to ignore this truth or you can pray about it with an open and believing mind and perhaps your own "record of heaven" may whisper the truth of it to you. Try the experiment and good luck
I'll just say that I respectfully disagree with you in regard to who the Holy Ghost is and how it operates in each of our lives and that's okay to believe differently!freedomforall wrote:Just reads the larger font and discover that I know what I'm talking about. The Holy Ghost has the power to be everywhere. Let's pose the question like this:rproe67 wrote:This is WAY TOO LONG and has been made complicated beyond belief! :ymsick: Then buy a slow watch, you can get more done that way. As for being too long, take it up with Marion G Romney. I am not the author of the message, only the messenger of it. Besides, take note of how many long posts are posted. One would think books are in the works. :ymsigh:
If I try to prove something using everyone else's words even a former "prophet", how can that be convincing?! I'm patiently learning that if I want to know truth, it has to come directly from God...to "my" spirit! O:-)
If the personage of Spirit known as the HG cannot be everywhere at the same time, then how is it that people all over the globe can feel his influence or get guidance from him, all simultaneously?
I just plain do not agree with some of the philosophy posted here, and nothing, nothing, says I have to. And to my knowledge...this is a two way street, right? I may not know all there is about the HG, but no one knows how the influence of the HG can be felt at the same time within a lot of people. So I stand with the view that the HG can be everywhere, by an unknown means, in helping people as needed. I never did say his person can be everywhere, however, his influence still emanates from him, everywhere. Some people are just not happy unless they can split hairs.boo wrote:FFA I am not sure but I may owe you an apology if you found my words offensive. I have reflected on what I said and in retrospect could have done a better job at expressing my frustration in responding to your questions. My weakness is that this is the 3rd time I have responded to a direct question from you on this thread in 2 days and each time my proffered response is either ignored or ridiculed. I suppose I should have dealt with my frustrations in a different manner. I will say it directly instead of indirectly. You are a remarkably difficult guy to communicate with and give me the strong impression that you have no interest in a dialogue with those whose views may differ from yours. You are certainly entitled to act in that fashion but it seems to me poor form to do so and then complain when some fallible guy like me responds in the same way I perceive you do . However I should not have acted that way I suppose and apologize for doing so.
I could care less, there are lurkers who just might take them as important. So you see whether you or anyone else on this forum reads them, it's no big deal, okay?rproe67 wrote:I'll just say that I respectfully disagree with you in regard to who the Holy Ghost is and how it operates in each of our lives and that's okay to believe differently!freedomforall wrote:Just reads the larger font and discover that I know what I'm talking about. The Holy Ghost has the power to be everywhere. Let's pose the question like this:rproe67 wrote:This is WAY TOO LONG and has been made complicated beyond belief! :ymsick: Then buy a slow watch, you can get more done that way. As for being too long, take it up with Marion G Romney. I am not the author of the message, only the messenger of it. Besides, take note of how many long posts are posted. One would think books are in the works. :ymsigh:
If I try to prove something using everyone else's words even a former "prophet", how can that be convincing?! I'm patiently learning that if I want to know truth, it has to come directly from God...to "my" spirit! O:-)
If the personage of Spirit known as the HG cannot be everywhere at the same time, then how is it that people all over the globe can feel his influence or get guidance from him, all simultaneously?
I'm not on a desktop computer or laptop so scrolling through the posts of quotes in both large and small fonts on a phone can make one dizzy and feel sick. Yes not your problem, next time I'll try to skip past your posts! :p