My view is we're not in a death spiral. I don't see how the words of the prophet support or deny that. The Mummy in fact did either ignore all the good news I posted, or search for the most negative spin he could. At which point it was rather clear she is married to doom and gloom (especially following her end of the world 2011 prophecy, the spiraling downward statements, etc.), and so I switched to what I saw as appropriate prophetic counsel. I pretty much ignored everything the Mummy wrote for the last two+ pages. (Actually, I'll let you in on a little secret: I could make every one of the Mummy's points if I wanted to. I had read just about every source she posted, minus the zerotic hedge stuff, prior to the posting.)give_me_liberty wrote:If we let pessimism paralyze us into inaction, nothing improves.
If we let optimism blind us from the truth, causing inaction, nothing improves.
JMarsigli, you are correct that we need to be optimistic, and we should probably focus a lot more on the good things than we do. However, like many things that are great to a point, it can be taken in the wrong direction.
Either we are in recovery or we are not. We can't say "I am being optimistic, and there IS some good news about the economy, therefore we must be recovering." I have seen you accuse Mummy and OI of being too pessimistic, ignoring the good news, and ignoring quotes from prophets that support your view.
Well said. I disagree with you, however, and never said things were all rosy. I said we are not in a death spiral. OI put those words in my mouth, apparently to score more points, and I guess you've taken him at his word. Actually, I'm sure you read where I said it would be a tough slog for a few years (I said this 2x). So I guess I don't see how you can accuse me of ignoring the pessimism when I've put up some obstacles myself.give_me_liberty wrote:However, you are being equally 'too optimistic' (optimistic to the point that you may not always be willing to hear the truth if it sounds pessimistic), ignoring the 'bad' news, and ignoring quotes from prophets that do not support your point of view. I hope I am getting the right point across when I say "too optimistic". As long as we don't get too comfortable and stop working for improvement or denying that something is a problem that needs to be fixed, we can't be optimistic enough. Once we go beyond that point though, we are counterproductive and are little better off than the pessimists.
What is true is true whether you are optimistic or pessimistic. What matters is seeing the truth and doing something about it, being optimistic (having faith) that our efforts will be worthwhile and that we are on God's side.
Why don't you give me the words of the prophets and show me what I've ignored rather than accusing me of doing so without pointing to any specifics. I've posted parts of 5 or so talks over the last couple of days, and have given a link to each of them. If you want to accuse me of it, and if you are actually being sincere, then please back it up so I can at least attempt to correct my errors. If you're sincere then I'll listen to you. OI is not. OI has been following me around offering various psychoanalyses, then asking for solidarity [out of the other side of his mouth]. I see no sincerity there and have responded accordingly.
Thank you.
Actually, Why did you chose to take issue with what I have written rather than the 3 or 4 who automatically wrote off the quotes I put up (and I was the only one quoting prophets, mind you), and mocked and ridiculed them? I'd think that would be more of a priority.
